I am really impressed by Whitaker. He's a very good striker,
He beat both Jacare and Romero, two great athletes. He basically cleaned up his division
and now Bisping is in deep shit as well.
Whittaker's been making a name for himself and it's hard to leave him off the list based on results. However, he struggled in spots with Hester, barely beat Hall and also struggled early with Brunson. Pressure is a problem for him, and he got knocked out by the only elite striker he fought in Wonderboy. Romero also won the first two rounds and Whittaker didn't pull ahead until Romero gassed significantly, but he still couldn't put away a fighter who was barely even throwing back. Romero wasn't ever really in much trouble despite the fatigue. MW is pretty devoid of striking talent so it's not his fault for not fighting great strikers, but we'll see how he fares against Bisping before I commit to ranking him among the elite. I'd also have liked to see him fight someone like Mousasi (can't believe they let him go), Weidman, Silva or Rockhold to get an idea of where he stands on the feet. Fuck it, I'd love to see him against Gastelum.
Side note, I've seen a lot of talk about how deep MW is recently, but I don't believe that's true. Bisping is about to retire, Romero is a freak and all but still over 40, Jacare's getting old and has lost 2 of his past 4, Weidman's been finished 3 times in a row, Rockhold is MIA (waiting for Bisping to retire?), Silva's also over 40 and just fucking around at this point, Brunson is pretty good but has lost to Jacare, Romero, Whittaker and Silva so I doubt he'll be elite, Branch is pretty good but 35, I guess Jotko still has potential but he just lost to Branch, Vitor is a dinosaur and hit gatekeeper status at this point, Hall's on a three fight losing streak and has been stopped in two of those, Mousasi signed to fucking Bellator even though he was just hitting his stride and won 5 in a row, the last 4 by fucking TKO. The future of MW is only Whittaker, Gastelum (if he makes weight and doesn't get suspended for getting high) and Rockhold for sure. MAYBE Jotko, maybe Branch, maybe Brunson, maybe Jacare goes on a late career warpath like Maia after losing to Rory. Overall though, compare it to a division like FW where you have an amazing top 5 (Holloway, Aldo, Edgar, Mendes, Cub) and fantastic up and coming talent like Choi, Bektic, T-City, KZ and Rodriguez, as well as a stable of skilled veterans like Stephens, Lamas and Elkins. That's a deep division, both now and in the foreseeable future, which is why I rank strikers at the top of it like Holloway, Aldo and McGregor so highly.