Your life depends on which Quarterback you choose to win one game

[Corona]

Brady just made the playoffs without all of that bullshit. Get a new argument.

making the playoffs doesn’t equate to picking one qb to win a game if your life depended on it.

 

[MrPilot22]

Rodgers and Brady, nobody else

 

[Jack Handy jr]

against my lions no less smh Detroit lions=worst pro sports franchise in American history

 

[paratiddies]

Somebody who can do it all, so Rodgers followed by Wilson

Definitely not a guy who forgets what down it is late in games

 

[Plissken]

Does Brady come with belicheck, his defense, and Adam vinateri? Lmao

What options don't have hof coaches and players with them? Montana, Marino, P. Manning, Brees, Rodgers, etc. all have had them.

 

[Corona]

What options don't have hof coaches and players with them? Montana, Marino, P. Manning, Brees, Rodgers, etc. all have had them.

what hof coach has Rodgers had? Mike McCarthy? Lmfao

 

[Madmick]

what hof coach has Rodgers had? Mike McCarthy? Lmfao

What is Beli's record without Brady, again?

 

[newcastleman]

I only watched American Football in the 80s and early 90s. From what I saw, I'd choose Joe Montana. Tremendous under pressure.

 

[rearnakedchoke]

Brady
Montana
Elway

guys like Peyton and Rodgers have shown they buckle under pressure more than the rest.

 

[PurpleStorm]

Joe Montana
Among active quarterbacks: ask again after the playoffs. Right now I'd say Aaron Rogers.

 

[chance mccoy]

Rodgers

 

[Bamboozled]

What is Beli's record without Brady, again?

What's McCarthy's record without Rodgers again?

 

[Madmick]

What's McCarthy's record without Rodgers again?

You lost control of the point your side was trying to prove here, chief, because you just argued Tom's greatness by analogy to Rodgers, rather than continuing the attempt to argue Rodger's superiority by virtue of McCarthy's inferiority to Belichick. Might help if you figured out the underlying logic as an endgame before you wade in.


Moreover, I realize you don't know much about football, but would it kill you to actually learn the answers to the dumb shit that comes out of your mouth before you allow it to spill?

McCarthy (with Rodgers fielded)
Packers: 99-58 (63.1%)
2006: 0-2
2007: 1-1
2008: 6-10
2009: 11-5
2010: 10-5
2011: 14-1
2012: 11-5
2013: 6-3
2014: 12-4
2015: 10-6
2016: 10-6
2017: 4-3
2018: 4-7
Overall (with): 99-58 (63.1%)

McCarthy (without Rodgers ever taking the field)
Packers: 26-19-1 (56.5%)
2006: 8-6
2007: 12-2
2008: 0-0
2009: 0-0
2010: 0-1
2011: 1-0
2012: 0-0
2013: 2-4-1
2014: 0-0
2015: 0-0
2016: 0-0
2017: 3-6
2018: 0-0
Cowboys: 6-10 (37.5%)
Overall (w/o): 32-29-1 (51.6%)


Note that McCarthy's record on the Packers with only Favre fielded was higher (20-8, 71.4%) than it was with Rodgers. But to answer your question asking what McCarthy's record has been without Rodgers?

A winning one. Unlike Belichick's.

 

[Bamboozled]

You lost control of the point your side was trying to prove here, chief, because you just argued Tom's greatness by analogy to Rodgers, rather than continuing the attempt to argue Rodger's superiority by virtue of McCarthy's inferiority to Belichick. Might help if you figured out the underlying logic as an endgame before you wade in.


Moreover, I realize you don't know much about football, but would it kill you to actually learn the answers to the dumb shit that comes out of your mouth before you allow it to spill?

McCarthy (with Rodgers fielded)
Packers: 99-58 (63.1%)
2006: 0-2
2007: 1-1
2008: 6-10
2009: 11-5
2010: 10-5
2011: 14-1
2012: 11-5
2013: 6-3
2014: 12-4
2015: 10-6
2016: 10-6
2017: 4-3
2018: 4-7
Overall (with): 99-58 (63.1%)

McCarthy (without Rodgers ever taking the field)
Packers: 26-19-1 (56.5%)
2006: 8-6
2007: 12-2
2008: 0-0
2009: 0-0
2010: 0-1
2011: 1-0
2012: 0-0
2013: 2-4-1
2014: 0-0
2015: 0-0
2016: 0-0
2017: 3-6
2018: 0-0
Cowboys: 6-10 (37.5%)
Overall (w/o): 32-29-1 (51.6%)


Note that McCarthy's record on the Packers with only Favre fielded was higher (20-8, 71.4%) than it was with Rodgers. But to answer your question asking what McCarthy's record has been without Rodgers?

A winning one. Unlike Belichick's.

lol @ anyone reading that shit

Mick, I'll give you credit, your spread for Brady is the stuff of legend. But you attribute things to him that aren't his responsibility.

 

[Madmick]

lol @ anyone reading that shit

Mick, I'll give you credit, your spread for Brady is the stuff of legend. But you attribute things to him that aren't his responsibility.

Concession accepted.

 

[lweiberg]

 

[lifelessheap]

What options don't have hof coaches and players with them? Montana, Marino, P. Manning, Brees, Rodgers, etc. all have had them.

Rodgers had Fat retarded Mike and Ted Thompson.

 

[ineverpost]

No matter how far back his men go he would still overthrow them by 10 yards. At #2 he might be one of the worst draft picks of all time.

 

[Deleted member 506663]

Jim Thorpe, don't need a QB

 

[TeTe]

Fitzmagic of course