Your life depends on which Quarterback you choose to win one game

[Jack Handy jr]

I've got to go with this guy


followed by

2.Elway

3.Payton

4.Brady

5.Jim Kelly

6.Steve Young

7. Aaron Rodgers

8.Brett Favre

9.Patrick Mahomes

10.Ben Rothelisberger

hon mentions, Aikman, Brees, Russell Wilson

What say you?

 

[Simple Southerner]

Tbh 12 but of course especially if its a 4th quarter drive . And damn ts mahones @ 9 ? Geez

 

[Jack Handy jr]

Tbh 12 but of course especially if its a 4th quarter drive . And damn ts mahones @ 9 ? Geez

Too soon? Maybe but I’ve drank the kook aide on this kid

if he stays healthy and they upgrade the line I could see him being top ten maybe give all time barring injury

 

[Shido4.20]

Godgers

 

[faustian]

Dan Marino
Kurt Warner
Rodney Peete

 

[Streeter]

I've got to go with this guy


followed by

2.Elway

3.Payton

4.Brady

5.Jim Kelly

6.Steve Young

7. Aaron Rodgers

8.Brett Favre

9.Patrick Mahomes

10.Ben Rothelisberger

hon mentions, Aikman, Brees, Russell Wilson

What say you?

Meh.

You got #1 right tho.


Elway always used to choke as did Peytonn especially Jim Kelly the choke king of the NFL..

TOP 3 ARE

1. MONTANA
2. BRADY
3. RODGERS

 

[Domitian]

Brees

 

[JackWhite]

Payton before Brady? Yikes.

 

[Corona]

Does Brady come with belicheck, his defense, and Adam vinateri? Lmao

 

[jrams]

 

[My Spot]

 

[Deffid]

All other things (special teams, coaching, defense, O-Line, supporting cast etc.) equal, Mahomes or Rodgers. Both have insane arms, both don't turn the ball over a lot, both can make those special plays.

 

[Bamboozled]

Probably Matthew Stafford tbh, assuming it comes down to a game winning drive

If it's just a game? Then GOAT Allen.

 

[Lethal_Striker]

Tim Tebow because he has the power of christ on his side...

 

[Dirt Road Soldier]

Grossman. Fuck it, go deep!

 

[Partlow]

Smokin Jay no doubt in my mind

 

[Finding Deebo]

Shane Falco....

 

[LazaRRus]

Willie Beamon

 

[Fugazy]

Today?

Obviously Mahomo

 

[haysus31]

Montana
Brady
Elway
Rodgers
Honorable mention Russell Wilson. The ability to escape and throw on the run that him and rodgers have can keep plays alive