You can't be the GOAT if you are knocked down by Michael Bisping

[BoxingFan653]

LOL

Ah cmon Fedor got KO'd by Dan Henderson a true middleweight. Age is the undefeated GOAT

 

[Hallelujah]

Agreed. You also can't be GOAT if:

You get KTFO in 13 seconds
You're a HW who gets KTFO by a MW
You tap to strikes in the hands of Matt Serra

So who was GOAT?

This guy never lost in any of those ways therefor goat.

 

[Apocalypse604]

Same Silva as before, just the hype machine isn't there.
People were broke before he got in the cage.

This silva is also 40 and past his prime.

 

[RexChapmanFan]

Same Silva as before, just the hype machine isn't there.
People were broke before he got in the cage.

Only quibble here is that prime Silva was in fact better than today mostly because he was maximizing PED intake back then.

 

[LouisBolanos]

This guy never lost in any of those ways therefor goat.

DATSIK MASTER GOAT!

 

[100action]

you cant be goat if your a HW that gets finished in round one by a middleweight

A MW on TRT that happen to be one of the all time greats with possibly the most KO power of any fighter?

Substantially different to losing to Bisping I would have thought.

 

[LouisBolanos]

Jones

No GOAT. GOATs don't lose to:

Deaf people
Lamppost
Pregnant woman

 

[UFCfan91]

A MW on TRT that happen to be one of the all time greats with possibly the most KO power of any fighter?

Substantially different to losing to Bisping I would have thought.

you clearly didnt get my point

what i was saying is that what happens when you are at the end of your career way past your prime has zero effect on whether you are the best of all time or not

 

[PancraseForever]

Getting knocked down by Chael is just as bad.

 

[airic_15]

everyone gets old man

 

[TheIrishPsycho]

Agreed. You also can't be GOAT if:

You get KTFO in 13 seconds
You're a HW who gets KTFO by a MW
You tap to strikes in the hands of Matt Serra

So who was GOAT?

Jon Jones....he's been the GOAT since he beat DC

 

[LouisBolanos]

Jon Jones....he's been the GOAT since he beat DC

A deaf kid, a lamppost and a pregnant woman all beat him. He no GOAT.

 

[TheIrishPsycho]

A deaf kid, a lamppost and a pregnant woman all beat him. He no GOAT.

He's free and walking the streets no?

That lamppost is overrated and the pregnant woman was on TRT.

 

[milenss]

you cant be goat if your a HW that gets finished in round one by a middleweight

Dan was a LHW at that time. Don't speculate with that. And Fedor fought at the unnatural catchweight, by the tail end of his prime.
Fedor knocked Henderson down. He won the standup.

 

[Mr.Maelstrom]

STFU, Mike's a fuggin gangster. He brought the heart today, dude

 

[RNC&Poke]

Or when you get KOd by Matt Serra, for all those saying GSP is GOAT.

 

[threelions]

everyone gets old man

Or stops taking their vitamins.

 

[KO Face]

Phil Baroni is the goat.

 

[Big Tuppy Hole]

Hes 40 and on the decline

LOL

 

[Noleggeisha]

Anderson Silva is the GOAT and deserves everyone's respect.