Who is the most inconsistent fighter in your opinion?

[kikikhan]

My vote goes to Big Foot.

This guy can beat anyone and is tough as hell in some fights, but then come fights where he is fragile like a child. I mean WTF is that?

Even his speed and movement is very different from fight to fight.

 

[CPH]

Ellenberger. He keeps me flip-flopping between belief and despair. It's all in his head.

 

[Tamriel Terror]

george roop, ellenburger, lauzon to name a few

 

[toe hold]

My vote goes to Big Foot.

Hard to put that label on someone (Bigfoot, Overeem) in the HW division as quickly as those fights can end.

Jake Ellenberger, Edson Barboza, Abel Trujillo, Charles Oliveira, Ian McCall

until recently Michael Johnson.

young guys improve, or get left behind.

 

[mma2013]

ellenburger

 

[CereserBr]

shogun

 

[Hans Gercmiov]

First name I thought of is Erick Silva.

 

[Senzo Tanaka]

Shogun or Bigfoot.

Both either KO someone or look horrible.

 

[in the liver]

mir

 

[BoricuaBryan]

Houston Alexander.

Honorable mention Frank Mir.

 

[Giovanefugazza]

Rampage

 

[El Fernas]

Overeem.

 

[Wardu1]

My vote goes to Big Foot.

This guy can beat anyone and is tough as hell in some fights, but then come fights where he is fragile like a child. I mean WTF is that?

Even his speed and movement is very different from fight to fight.

What you are seeing is Bigfoot on trt and Bigfoot offbof trt. My answer is struve

 

[cumafish]

Melvin Guillard

 

[Fujita]

Randleman but that was due to competition.

 

[Mikedh]

Josh Thomson and Takeya Mizugaki in my opinion seem to fight to their opponents level. You see them have close fights with mid to bottom tier type talent but then you also see them have close fights with top ten guys.

 

[kikikhan]

Hard to put that label on someone in the HW division as quickly as those fights can end.

Hahahaha. Well that is pretty good answer

But Big Foot is just weirder

 

[kikikhan]

What you are seeing is Bigfoot on trt and Bigfoot offbof trt. My answer is struve

I saw this before Big Foot got taken of TRT.

 

[kikikhan]

Randleman but that was due to competition.

KOing CC was not due to competition

Randleman was strong and dangerous as a bull, but he was also as smart

 

[Lucifer Alpha]

He seems to have turned a corner, but it's hard to forget Michael Johnson's back-to-back piss-poor performances against Jury and Madadi.