Discussion in 'Mayberry Lounge' started by MXZT, Aug 11, 2016.
Hamill's version is the GOAT, but will always be underappreciated because it didn't happen on the same stage as the big Hollywood blockbusters.
Mark Hamill by far.
But every actor brings something to the role. He was just the best...
Shit where to start? 20+ Years as Joker
^GOAT Joker laugh too
Hamill. He's instantly the voice that comes into my head when the Joker is mentioned.
Heath wins for live action version.
The one in the comics.
I give the nod to ledger only because a lot goes into the visual performance that hamill doesn't have to deal with.
If we're just judging the vocal performance then Hamill wins
Not only that but Kevin Conroy is GOAT Batman
too bad they couldn't play them in a live-action
Well they could... if it was a Batman Beyond movie as old Bruce. That's about it at this point.
True, but I'm talking about if they were in their prime.
And I hope they make an Batman Beyond some day.
It's all preference, if you're looking for the best representation/adaptation of The Joker from the comics than it would probably look like:
Hamill joker voice sounds too over the top to take seriously....probably because it's designed for a fucking Saturday morning cartoon...for kids.
Let me say that again
A fucking Saturday morning cartoon. Never mind that hamill is only one half of the performance and the animators would be the other half.
So no. It's not hamill. I know that's the trendy obscure answer, but it's wrong. A Saturday morning cartoon can't trump live acting by an actor...in the flesh...
It would be like saying the one in the comics was best...
Oh...ok. Sure. Voiced by the sound in your head! Right? Of course that joker would be bang on, it's fuelled by your imaginations perfect take on the joker...lol.
It's ledger...followed by Nicholson.
Lol mark hamill...
Hamill>Nicholson>Ledger>Romero so far. Although I must say that Romero freaked me the fuck out as a kid.
i am partial to Sal. But Joe can really bring it sometimes. they are all great though
I desperately wanted to vote for Jack, but I had to give it to Heath. His performance was undeniably great.
stop the fuckin hate!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ledger numero uno with hamill and nicholson vying for 2nd in a competitive 5 round war.
Nicholson's Joker hasnt aged that well,to me. That whole movie....it just seems dated when i watch it now.
I love Mark Hamill and all but that's a cartoon And he's doing a voice over.
Heath is the best joker ever
It's campy and most certainly has not aged well