- Joined
- Sep 2, 2018
- Messages
- 655
- Reaction score
- 0
Conor nate wasn't close Conor won 3-4 rounds no problem
Who do you think won these close fights
- Thread starter XThe GreatestX
- Start date
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2012
- Messages
- 17,263
- Reaction score
- 6,139
So you disagree with yourself?
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2010
- Messages
- 6,930
- Reaction score
- 2,472
GSP
Conor
Machida, by a huge margin. There’s a reason why Rampge was completely shocked that his hand was raised.
Condit
Jones, a close fight, but the rounds were pretty clear. None of the rounds could honestly be argued as possibly going the other way.
Condit
Don’t remember BJ - Edgar well enough
Machida, but would not have had any issue with a split decision going the other way. Was surprised it was not a split decision. Joe Rogan’s announcng was really a disservice to what should have been a beautiful fight for the fans.
Didn’t see BJ GSP 1.
- Joined
- Sep 5, 2014
- Messages
- 17,463
- Reaction score
- 7,965
GSP vs Hendricks = Hendricks 48-47, I don't think GSP did enough to win 3 rounds so I'll call it a robbery
McGregor vs Diaz II = McGregor 3-2 (not sure if I had it 48-47 or something else though)
Rampage vs Machida = Machida 29-28, he landed the better shots than Rampage in round 1
Lawler vs Condit = I had it 3-2 Lawler but it was super close
Jones vs Gustafsson = I have changed my stance twice on this one but in the end I have it Jones 48-47
Condit vs Diaz = Condit won but don't remember exactly how I scored it
Penn vs Edgar 1 = Penn 48-47
Shogun vs Machida 1 = Straight up robbery, Shogun won either 3-2 or 4-1
GSP vs Penn 1 = I had it GSP 29-28 but don't remember much, would need to rewatch
McGregor vs Diaz II = McGregor 3-2 (not sure if I had it 48-47 or something else though)
Rampage vs Machida = Machida 29-28, he landed the better shots than Rampage in round 1
Lawler vs Condit = I had it 3-2 Lawler but it was super close
Jones vs Gustafsson = I have changed my stance twice on this one but in the end I have it Jones 48-47
Condit vs Diaz = Condit won but don't remember exactly how I scored it
Penn vs Edgar 1 = Penn 48-47
Shogun vs Machida 1 = Straight up robbery, Shogun won either 3-2 or 4-1
GSP vs Penn 1 = I had it GSP 29-28 but don't remember much, would need to rewatch
- Joined
- Sep 15, 2017
- Messages
- 1,812
- Reaction score
- 114
GSP/Hendricks - GSP 3-2
McGregor/Diaz II - Draw, wasn't upset about the MD though.
Rampage/Machida - Machida 2-1
Lawler/Condit - Condit 3-2
Jones/Gus - Jones 3-2, very close to a draw though IMO.
Diaz/Condit - Condit 3-2
Penn/Edgar I - BJ 3-2
Shogun/Machida I - Shogun 3-2
Penn/GSP I - GSP 2-1 but could've gone the other way
McGregor/Diaz II - Draw, wasn't upset about the MD though.
Rampage/Machida - Machida 2-1
Lawler/Condit - Condit 3-2
Jones/Gus - Jones 3-2, very close to a draw though IMO.
Diaz/Condit - Condit 3-2
Penn/Edgar I - BJ 3-2
Shogun/Machida I - Shogun 3-2
Penn/GSP I - GSP 2-1 but could've gone the other way
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2011
- Messages
- 19,594
- Reaction score
- 309
Gsp
Nate
Rampage
Lawler
Jones
Diaz
Bj
Shogun
Gsp
Nate
Rampage
Lawler
Jones
Diaz
Bj
Shogun
Gsp
- Joined
- Nov 2, 2017
- Messages
- 9,888
- Reaction score
- 9,563
- Joined
- Feb 3, 2013
- Messages
- 25,562
- Reaction score
- 7,774
GSP- Hendricks
GSP. Johnny gave away the last round
Conor- Nate II
Conor
Rampage- Machida
I expected Machida to get a win but it was very close
Lawler-Condit
Condit
Gus-Jones
Jones
Condit-Diaz
Condit - but I was pissed at his gameplan
Bj-Frankie I
BJ
Shogun-Machida I
Shogun
BJ-GSP 1
BJ
GSP. Johnny gave away the last round
Conor- Nate II
Conor
Rampage- Machida
I expected Machida to get a win but it was very close
Lawler-Condit
Condit
Gus-Jones
Jones
Condit-Diaz
Condit - but I was pissed at his gameplan
Bj-Frankie I
BJ
Shogun-Machida I
Shogun
BJ-GSP 1
BJ
- Joined
- May 30, 2011
- Messages
- 37,008
- Reaction score
- 9,180
GSP- Hendricks
Hendricks and it was not close.
Momentum was all on Hendricks side. GSP had nothing.
Not saying Hendricks is better than GSP, and if there was a rematch I sure think GSP would thoroughly beat Hendricks, but he lost that fight.
Conor- Nate II
Nate. Running from the fight should award one point deduction, and Conor did plenty of running.
Rampage- Machida
Machida. and again, not even close.
Lawler-Condit
Condit fanboys ALWAYS claim he won, no matter how thoroughly he's beaten.
Lawler beat the running men.
Gus-Jones
Gus. Another robbery because the other guy is a dominant favorite.
This is an issue with judges and their biased views. A challenger has to end the fight or the favorite champion wins.
Condit-Diaz
Another Condit fight. See above.
Bj-Frankie I
Frankie won. And proved every single BJ fanboys wrong. Then did it again. And again.
About time BJ Fanboys let it go.
Shogun-Machida I
As a huge Machida Fan, I am mad he won that fight.
I rather he would have lost than a win via judges highway robbery (a way I would think Jon Jones and GSP fanboys would share, but they are too blind)
BJ-GSP 1
GSP. Another BJ fanboys fight they can't stomach.
Unless vaseline did happen, then GSP should have been DQ'd.
But then again, far too long in the past to cry over it.
- Joined
- Sep 15, 2008
- Messages
- 27,773
- Reaction score
- 3,377
I'm with you except for 2 and a half...I had Riggs winning.....I had machida over Quinton and Condit- Diaz was the one that could of went either way. I agree with rest
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2012
- Messages
- 17,263
- Reaction score
- 6,139
I dont see how gsp beat bj the first time
Seriously gsp did NOTHING in that fight
Seriously gsp did NOTHING in that fight
- Joined
- Jun 17, 2008
- Messages
- 7,779
- Reaction score
- 2,070
All draws in my opinion. I don't feel the need to pick a winner, especially based on points. It's supposed to be a fight, points are dumb.
Makes a thread about close fights, includes fights that's weren't close at all
@XThe GreatestX
Conor vs Nate 2 wasn't a close fight at all lulz. It was a clinic. An outclassing. It's digusting how little respect Conor gets for this win
And Shogun CLEARLY beat Machida. To even give Machida 3 rounds is to give Machida the extreme benefit of the doubt, to the point where you are just sitting there blindly ignoring everything Shogun does with the sole intent to "score" the fight for Machida regardless of reality
Also Gus beat Jones but that fight is more debatable
@XThe GreatestX
Conor vs Nate 2 wasn't a close fight at all lulz. It was a clinic. An outclassing. It's digusting how little respect Conor gets for this win
And Shogun CLEARLY beat Machida. To even give Machida 3 rounds is to give Machida the extreme benefit of the doubt, to the point where you are just sitting there blindly ignoring everything Shogun does with the sole intent to "score" the fight for Machida regardless of reality
Also Gus beat Jones but that fight is more debatable
- Joined
- Nov 6, 2017
- Messages
- 1,089
- Reaction score
- 0
GSP- Hendricks
GSP
Conor- Nate II
Majority draw
Rampage- Machida
Machida
Lawler-Condit
Lawler
Gus-Jones
Jones
Condit-Diaz
Nick Diaz
Bj-Frankie I
Frankie
Shogun-Machida I
Machida
BJ-GSP 1
GSP
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2012
- Messages
- 17,263
- Reaction score
- 6,139
LolMakes a thread about close fights, includes fights that's weren't close at all
@XThe GreatestX
Conor vs Nate 2 wasn't a close fight at all lulz. It was a clinic. An outclassing. It's digusting how little respect Conor gets for this win
And Shogun CLEARLY beat Machida. To even give Machida 3 rounds is to give Machida the extreme benefit of the doubt, to the point where you are just sitting there blindly ignoring everything Shogun does with the sole intent to "score" the fight for Machida regardless of reality
Also Gus beat Jones but that fight is more debatable
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2004
- Messages
- 35,179
- Reaction score
- 9,558
GSP- Hendricks
all about round 1
Conor- Nate II
3-2 Conor clear as day
Rampage- Machida
2-1 Rampage. ironically, most think Rampage won round 1, most think Rampage won round 2, and most think Machida should have won the fight.
Lawler-Condit
3-2 condit
Gus-Jones
3-2 Jones clear as day
Condit-Diaz
Condit 4-1
Bj-Frankie I
3-2 BJ. I think round 3 was the only close round
Shogun-Machida I
Shogun 3-2 or 4-1
BJ-GSP 1
Bj 2-1 clear as day[/QUOTE]
all about round 1
Conor- Nate II
3-2 Conor clear as day
Rampage- Machida
2-1 Rampage. ironically, most think Rampage won round 1, most think Rampage won round 2, and most think Machida should have won the fight.
Lawler-Condit
3-2 condit
Gus-Jones
3-2 Jones clear as day
Condit-Diaz
Condit 4-1
Bj-Frankie I
3-2 BJ. I think round 3 was the only close round
Shogun-Machida I
Shogun 3-2 or 4-1
BJ-GSP 1
Bj 2-1 clear as day[/QUOTE]
- Joined
- Oct 25, 2017
- Messages
- 13,278
- Reaction score
- 5,531
I'm a huge GSP fan but after re-watching the fight I thought Hendricks narrowly edged Rd1 and should have gotten the decision. But it was a close fight, and under the 10-8 system could have gone either way.
I thought Conor clearly won 3 rounds to 2 and was surprised anyone though differently.
I don't remember the other fights clearly enough and never watched them again to comment.
I thought Conor clearly won 3 rounds to 2 and was surprised anyone though differently.
I don't remember the other fights clearly enough and never watched them again to comment.
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2004
- Messages
- 19,087
- Reaction score
- 2,380
GSP- Hendricks
hend
Conor- Nate II
3-2 conor.
Lawler-Condit
draw
Gus-Jones
3-2 Jones. r5 head kicks ftw
Condit-Diaz
3-2 condit.
Bj-Frankie I
3-2 BJ. maybe 4-1.
BJ-GSP 1
GSP , but it was close enough that people should give bj more respect
hend
Conor- Nate II
3-2 conor.
Lawler-Condit
draw
Gus-Jones
3-2 Jones. r5 head kicks ftw
Condit-Diaz
3-2 condit.
Bj-Frankie I
3-2 BJ. maybe 4-1.
BJ-GSP 1
GSP , but it was close enough that people should give bj more respect
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2006
- Messages
- 12,920
- Reaction score
- 20
GSP- Hendricks
Gsp
Conor- Nate II
Conor
Rampage- Machida
Machida
Lawler-Condit
Condit.
Gus-Jones
Jones.
Condit-Diaz
Condit
Bj-Frankie I
BJ.
Shogun-Machida I
Shogun
BJ-GSP 1
GSP
Gsp
Conor- Nate II
Conor
Rampage- Machida
Machida
Lawler-Condit
Condit.
Gus-Jones
Jones.
Condit-Diaz
Condit
Bj-Frankie I
BJ.
Shogun-Machida I
Shogun
BJ-GSP 1
GSP
