Where do you rank Riddick Bowe?

Virtually Identical

Orange Belt
@Orange
Joined
Feb 8, 2020
Messages
452
Reaction score
464
As the title states, I’m curious as to where my fellow sherbros rank Riddick Bowe?

personally speaking I got him as the second best HW of the Tyson Era behind Lewis and somewhere like 8-12 in terms of ATG HW rankings.

what’re your thoughts ?
 
well

i don’t have him in the top 10 atg
maybe top 15 i dunno

his legacy is hurt by his wasted career from 1993-1998ish

fought little to no one of note other than Evander

I actually think he would have beaten Lennox so missed opportunity there and didn’t get to fight Tyson

but he also didn’t even fight the midcarders of the era like ruddock or morrison

so what can ya do
 
Well, he beat Holyfield 2 outta 3 times. That’s definitely impressive. Even though Holyfield looked horribly off his game in that 3rd fight. Outside of that Holyfield trilogy though there’s really not a whole lot else to give him credit for. Although lots of his fights are exciting. Plus that: Kicks, press conference brawls, all out riots, etc. Never a dull moment lol. Not a win resume really worth writing home about though
 
All-time? He's definitely top 20 at heavyweight. He's arguably top 15.
 
Take away the Evander fights its pretty barren and he got pieced up by golota lol
His resume mirrors Tyson's in many ways. They share a lot of opponents. Take away two wins from Tyson (Michael Spinks/Larry Holmes, maybe) and who does Tyson have? Razor Ruddock? Frank Bruno?
 
#1 underachiever
 
skillswise I think he's up there with all of the GOATs but resume holds him back. Somewhere in the top 9-12 ATGs probably
 
Great offensive skillset. So-so resume given said skillset and the options he had. Top 20ish IMO.
 
very good on the night he beat holyfield, big man with great skills, on his best night, who knows what would happen, i think he would have beaten lewis in that time frame but his management was obviously scared of him. as far as all time? how many fighters have had one or two great nights? we can't really rank them amongst guys who've been at or near the top for ten/twenty years. so, not all time, on his best nights and for a short period, he was the best in the division. Edit: I repeated myself but I meant that he didn't have much of a constitution as far as the punishment of the game;not something he could control. Some guys like Holyfield can fight a million wars and come through ok, some guys can only fight one, bowe was more like the latter. Whatever he lost in the holyfield fights, Golota completely finished.
 
Last edited:
He never had Lewis’ discipline but I’ll be in the minority here to say he had a more diverse skillset.
 
on a side note I've heard Big Daddy was a genuine good guy
 
Not top 25, won his titles when Tyson was in prison, gave his titles up because he was afraid of Lennox from being beat by him in the Olympics years earlier. Was actually the 4th best of his era. Lewis, Holyfield, Tyson, then Bowe. Great record and beat Holyfield twice sure, but there were others from his era who he could have fought but didn't as well. I think at least early on Morrison would've given him all the trouble in the world.

Not to mention, that record isnt as clean as it looks, he got his ass whooped by Golota both fights. and 2 of the weakest title defenses in history
 
Not top 25, won his titles when Tyson was in prison, gave his titles up because he was afraid of Lennox from being beat by him in the Olympics years earlier. Was actually the 4th best of his era. Lewis, Holyfield, Tyson, then Bowe. Great record and beat Holyfield twice sure, but there were others from his era who he could have fought but didn't as well. I think at least early on Morrison would've given him all the trouble in the world.

Not to mention, that record isnt as clean as it looks, he got his ass whooped by Golota both fights. and 2 of the weakest title defenses in history
I watched it all play out, the two title defenses are par for the course for many a new heavyweight champ as they try to cash in before taking another risk. Then, he fought the very close rematch with Evander which really could have conceivably gone either way. After that, he was looking awful nearly every fight while the idiot boxing media was still propping him up as "maybe the real best heavyweight in the world". Should have gotten disqualified against Mathis, couldn't keep Hide down. Beat holyfield in the rubber match and then fell off the cliff against Golota. So, as far as accomplishment, he didn't fulfill his promise, he came in fat and out of shape for most of his later fights but he was still an amazing big man for the first two holyfield fights. It's pretty rare to see that much skill and craft in that big of a guy along with his great stamina. I still say that with what we now know about how little shelflife he had that maybe he never could have done much more, we didn't see that at the time.
 
I watched it all play out, the two title defenses are par for the course for many a new heavyweight champ as they try to cash in before taking another risk. Then, he fought the very close rematch with Evander which really could have conceivably gone either way. After that, he was looking awful nearly every fight while the idiot boxing media was still propping him up as "maybe the real best heavyweight in the world". Should have gotten disqualified against Mathis, couldn't keep Hide down. Beat holyfield in the rubber match and then fell off the cliff against Golota. So, as far as accomplishment, he didn't fulfill his promise, he came in fat and out of shape for most of his later fights but he was still an amazing big man for the first two holyfield fights. It's pretty rare to see that much skill and craft in that big of a guy along with his great stamina. I still say that with what we now know about how little shelflife he had that maybe he never could have done much more, we didn't see that at the time.
The purposeful ducking of Lewis holds him back though, it’s the most blatant duck in boxing history just about
 
The purposeful ducking of Lewis holds him back though, it’s the most blatant duck in boxing history just about
Truth is, most of the time a fighter "ducks" another, it's a managerial decision. Fighters, believe it or not , are usually not assertive in daily life.
 
Truth is, most of the time a fighter "ducks" another, it's a managerial decision. Fighters, believe it or not , are usually not assertive in daily life.
Which is why he ducked a mini tournament final he signed on for with Lewis and then after he made he 2 lame title defenses, he offered Lewis a 10% split of $32M HBO offered for the bout.
 
Back
Top