Ward vs Gatti II was probably as amped as I've ever been watching a fight. I remember watching it live and seeing it by myself and being so upset that there was no one else to wittness how good this fight is. I taped a replay on VHS and made people watch it with me after the fact.
It's a little different going back and watching older fights, because they're still exciting, but the stakes aren't there. You know how things worked out before you start watching. So Hagler Hearns is still amazing but it wasn't edge of my seat for me.