As far as the roster goes, it looks weak. Here are a few things I noticed:
1. A lot of names missing. Sure, they could add them in DLC, but honestly, are they really going to put in Pascal Krauss in the game but not Matt Brown or Stun Gun? Of all the prospects/mid-lower tier guys they could have used (if any), they pick Krauss? I have nothing bad to say about Krauss. I'm okay with him being in the game. But it just seems really random that out of the 90+ WWs on the roster, they include him and didn't include many more that would make just as much, if not more sense.
2. I like that you can use some guys in multiple weight classes. But it seems like they used that as a reason to not add more fighters to the roster. Why fill it up with more guys that actually compete there when you can just add some guys from other weight classes to more than one weight? It makes it look fuller without it actually being that way. What's worse is that you have guys who actually have moved weights that are only listed at one weight, while others who only compete at one weight who are listed in more than one. Frankie Edgar, the former LW champ appears to only be available at FW, but Korean Zombie is playable at LW?
3. With such a limited roster, it could really hurt career mode. Even if they have some generic guys for early competition, are they going to make them move up through the ranks like prospects, or will it be where you have the same handful of guys competing at the top for years?
This can still be a good game. But there are things I think should be done that would make the game much better.
1. Make it so you can create a whole lot of CAFs. I don't want to start making guys and be limited to like 10 or 20. I'd at least like to make 10 per divison.
2. Make it so you can add all of your CAFs to career mode. If I am allowed to make a lot of CAFs, and I take the time to do so, I would like to be able to have them all in the career mode. It would make for a much better experience so it's not just the same guys over and over again. In one of the old UFC games, Kongo was like a 5 time HW champ and had fought the same guys like 5 times each. A little realism can go a long way. Not saying an unsuspecting guy can't get the title, but if there are more guys fighting and they don't stick around for the whole career, you can get a little more variety in opponents and not have the same guys winning the title over and over and over again.
3. In career mode, guys should retire and new computer generated guys should come along, just like with any other sports title with seasons/careers. If I'm a 22 year old rookie, Dan Henderson shouldn't still be fighting when I retire at 37.
4. Adjustable stats. It would be nice if I could adjust the stats down the road to reflect the current roster. It would make the game much more relevant next year or even the year after that. If Pascal Krauss turns into the next Anderson Silva next year, it would be nice if I could adjust the stats to make him that good.
Hell, this might be a kick ass game no matter what they do. Also, for all of you who want more focus on gameplay and are less worried about the roster, I can appreciate that. Maybe you just use a couple of guys and do mostly online competition. But it would be nice for those of us who prefer a more accurate simulation and career mode to get something we can enjoy just as much too.