Nah, it's the goofy formatting too, not just the pics. You made it way harder than it needed to be. When it comes to this stuff Simplicity Is Power. You overcomplicated the shit out of it, so nobody's reading it, and those who are reading it aren't taking it seriously.
Should be more like this ...
2007
Most Popular - GSP, Chuck, Tito
Most Hated - Tito, Serra
Tito was polarizing af, so is on both lists.
2008
Most Popular - Brock, GSP
Most Hated - Rashad
Rashad had just KO'd the golden boy Chuck and touched his balls against Forrest, he got a lot of hate.
2009
Most Popular - Brock, GSP
Most Hated - Bisping, Rashad
Greasegate happened, but GSP remained beloved. Bisping made himself a menace on TUF.
etc ...