It sounds like a lot of you guys are spending too much time with women that don't know how to apply makeup properly. Of course, a shit ton of it done poorly is going to be a turn-off but when a woman really knows how to use just a wee bit at a time it's awesome.
Don't get me wrong, I love my wife's natural look too but when she decides that she wants to get dolled up when we go out somewhere the transformation from just a little bit of makeup here & there can be hot as hell. It should just accentuate their looks a bit though not make them look like someone else.
As for the body hair thing, no thanks. To each their own, man, but I like it when my wife is very well-groomed, thank you very much.