If the point is to find hidden gems, I think they are doing fine. People expect more out of these guys right out of the gate. That's the problem. People look at the fighters and think the days of potential title challengers are over. Maybe if our expectations were a little more realistic? Look at Neil Magny, for example. When both Colton Smith and Mike Ricci washed out of the UFC, that season looked like a massive bust. Maybe for the most part, it was. But nobody saw Magny coming.
But maybe that isn't enough. Maybe nobody wants to waste their time on a season in hopes that a Magny will come along. Maybe people would rather have more of a chance at either potential champs or at least a plethora of fighters with some staying power. If so, maybe they should go after some top unsigned talent, find a way to make it worth their while to be on the show, and do it that way.
Maybe another comeback season?
Maybe another HW season like TUF 10? TUF 10 sort of looked like a joke at face value. On the surface, it looked like a vehicle to get Kimbo Slice into the UFC and benefit from his star power. Then, for anyone in the know, you had the real favorite, Roy Nelson. After all, a chunk of the contestants were former football players looking for a MMA career. Ironically, a few of the more successful ones were former football players with little to no MMA expereince. Maybe they should try looking for the next Brendan Schaub or the next Matt Mitrione.