the top GOATS

[squatchi26]

we can all agree when it comes to GOATS the names Fedor, Silva and GSP are always at the top but what about Dan Henderson? We all know he is great and probably in most's top 5 but will anyone make an argument that he the #1 GOAT? Even though he has a few losses, one to Silva, can anyone deny that he has the GOAT resume as far as opponents? Aside from Jones does anyone come close to that list?

 

[Drake]

1. GSP
2. Fedor
3. Jones
4. Silva
5. Cruz


I had GSP & Fedor tied at #1 until today.

 

[Soul On Ice]

Anderson
Jones
GSP
Fedor

No other names are GOAT status.

 

[Glove]

1. GSP
2. Fedor
3. Jones
4. Silva
5. Cruz


I had GSP & Fedor tied at #1 until today.

That's a very solid list, im curious, who would you put as the next five in your (GOAT) list? Or do you even have five that would be labeled as such.

 

[Hans Gercmiov]

Jones, Anderson, GSP, Fedor, Aldo.

I struggle with myself everytime I make this list.

 

[TheComebackKid]

Anderson
Jones
Fedor
GSP

Those are the P4P GOATs and Henderson isn't one of them.

Penn
Aldo
Cruz
Mighty Mouse
Ronda
JJ

Those are the divisional GOATs and Henderson is not one of them either.

But with that said Henderson would be top 10 on the all time list imo.

 

[muaymilk]

Anderson is the goat of the goats. The other goats make cheese. Anderson kicks it with the head farmer.

Anderson Silva - best of all time. Any weight class, any time period.

 

[Hans Gercmiov]

Anderson
Jones
GSP
Fedor

No other names are GOAT status.

Aldo deserves mention. He's earned his place imo.

 

[Summoning]

 

[bubby]

1. Fedor/jones, and it is hard to decide.
2/3. Gsp
3/4. Silva

Johnson might move up one or two places depending on his next few fights, and Cruz is up there, too, but that is my GOAT list.

Also, fuck anyone that doesn't include jones. He didn't crash into YOUR car.

 

[Drake]

That's a very solid list, im curious, who would you put as the next five in your (GOAT) list? Or do you even have five that would be labeled as such.

I don't think about the back five enough to give a solid list besides Aldo & MM tied at #6. So then for the three after i'd have to give some thought.

 

[muaytao]

mighty mouse. jones. anderson.

 

[Mondo Freaks]

Jones
GSP
Cruz
MM

Anderson and Fedor are off the list for now.

 

[Claude]

Fedor.

 

[Hans Gercmiov]

Anderson is the goat of the goats. The other goats make cheese. Anderson kicks it with the head farmer.

Anderson Silva - best of all time. Any weight class, any time period.

I disagree with you, even though Anderson Silva is not only my favorite fighter, but one of my favorite world figures of all time. I have a framed photo of both him and my other hero Albert Einstien on my wall. I've often thought if I ever have a son I'll name him Anderson.

Jon Jones >>>>>>

 

[bubby]

Anderson
Jones
Fedor
GSP

Those are the P4P GOATs and Henderson isn't one of them.

Penn
Aldo
Cruz
Mighty Mouse
Ronda
JJ

Those are the divisional GOATs and Henderson is not one of them either.

But with that said Henderson would be top 10 on the all time list imo.

Henderson matches penn's best achievement by being a two division title holder and had a vastly better career overall. If you list penn, you have to list Hendo.

 

[TheComebackKid]

Henderson matches penn's best achievement by being a two division title holder and had a vastly better career overall. If you list penn, you have to list Hendo.

I don't put any of the divisional GOATs ahead of Hendo except maybe Aldo. Hendo > Penn for sure.

 

[Perrichet]

GSP
Jones
Fedor
The rest

 

[Me&MrJones]

Greatest of All Time.

Top 15?

 

[Sirwastealot]

It used to be 3 now its 4.

Fedor, GSP, Silva, Jones. And then the rest. Hendo doesn't break into that top 4.