- Joined
- Jun 11, 2008
- Messages
- 5,462
- Reaction score
- 12
just wanna share and please share your thoughts and there stand-up technique.
[YT]phmcyZSMrw0&feature=related[/YT]
[YT]phmcyZSMrw0&feature=related[/YT]
My dragon style WILL defeat your tiger style.
I am suprised the monk repeatly leans backwards when he kicks. I've done muay thai and taekwondo (WTF) before and it was discouraged since its easy to lose one's balance that way...
If you're asking if Enter the Dragon is the great MA movie of all time, I'd say maybe, Jet Li in his early career had some good ones. I can't think of the name but the one where he opens the movie by knee barring the guy standing up is a good one.
I am suprised the monk repeatly leans backwards when he kicks. I've done muay thai and taekwondo (WTF) before and it was discouraged since its easy to lose one's balance that way...
Don't you take boxing as well? Even in boxing you don't lean with your back, you lean with your body and hips. That's why I want to see a proper boxer destroy Anderson Silva's silly movements. Chael did it pretty well in their first fight, especially in the 1st round.
Ignoring the jibber jabber about enter the dragon and anderson silva, I thought the video in question was pretty ridiculous.
The technique they were showcasing over and over again is actually fine (the kick counter where he sweeps the leg out). I've seen it done in actual competition settings, especially modified versions in muay thai. Its actually fairly common, but still rare enough that when you see someone pull it off you stop and say, "Damn, that was beautiful".
That said, I seriously doubt anyone in this video had the skill to actually apply the technique in and mid to high level competition. It was all very choreographed. And the portions that were't choreographed (i.e. the shirtless guy kicking the bags and pads) made me cringe. He showed what I consider to be poor technique. Hands down, flat footed, off balance, etc.
The rest of the video was filled with hype about kung fu hidden secrets based on deadly animal movements, interspersed with some of the b.s. breaking demos that are widely known to be simple, albeit painful tricks. I refer to breaking iron per the head, and hammers smashing bricks on the skull.
I have seen traditional kung fu guys who were skilled and badass. I have seen sanda guys who could beat anyone's ass in the ring. This video doesn't have a hint of either one of these, just a bastardized version of both. Look somewhere else for technique.
good video , thanks for sharing ,
just to let the bashers know that most of what you are taught today , derives from kung fu , karate of the past , instead of bashing it , watch his footwork , his timing , when he retreats and when he attacks , the very end of the video when he is showing the side step , is a gem by itself , he has angled off , went from a backwards motion to a circular forward motion and attacked with bassically two steps , his front foot hardley touches the floor and he is back in range again , beautiful ,kinda looks like what machida does , hey , instead of wondering how anderson silva has an uncanny ability to counter like that , the monk just showed you , peace out
martial arts derived from india == a few thousand years ago
kung fu was developed from that art ==== couple thousand years ago
modern day karate was developed from kung fu and others == couple hundred years ago
modern day tae kwon do === within 60 years
modern day judo === within a hundred years
brasilian jiu jitsu from judo == within 80 years
modern day western boxing === 1800s
mixed martial arts === within 20 years
im guessing at the dates , just trying to show the roots of martial arts and how the ancient movements have grown into what we do today ,,,, kung fu says == whos your daddy ?
This coming from a TMA guy: European boxing and wrestling has no roots in Kung Fu. Ancient Greeks practiced bare-knuckle boxing and wrestling almost 3 thousand years ago and Pankration (the oldest MMA-like sport known to man) was introduced into the Greek Olympic Games in 648 BC.
Theres actually no evidence kung fu evolved from Indian martial arts.
The only link to said thoery is the legend of damo and that has been proven to be false as he didnt know martial arts at all.
good video , thanks for sharing ,
just to let the bashers know that most of what you are taught today , derives from kung fu , karate of the past , instead of bashing it , watch his footwork , his timing , when he retreats and when he attacks , the very end of the video when he is showing the side step , is a gem by itself , he has angled off , went from a backwards motion to a circular forward motion and attacked with bassically two steps , his front foot hardley touches the floor and he is back in range again , beautiful ,kinda looks like what machida does , hey , instead of wondering how anderson silva has an uncanny ability to counter like that , the monk just showed you , peace out
martial arts derived from india == a few thousand years ago
kung fu was developed from that art ==== couple thousand years ago
modern day karate was developed from kung fu and others == couple hundred years ago
modern day tae kwon do === within 60 years
modern day judo === within a hundred years
brasilian jiu jitsu from judo == within 80 years
modern day western boxing === 1800s
mixed martial arts === within 20 years
im guessing at the dates , just trying to show the roots of martial arts and how the ancient movements have grown into what we do today ,,,, kung fu says == whos your daddy ?
First off, no one is bashing kung fu or sanda. These guys just don't display either. Not very well anyway. Try reading a bit more critically.
As someone else pointed out, your beliefs about origins of martial arts are wrong. Martial arts have evolved all over the world, at all different times. It's not the linear point a to point b you seem to think. Martial arts in china predate buddhism, by several centuries, so some traveling monk from india did not teach kung fu to the chinese. Has kung fu had an influence on martial arts? Yes. Is it the fountain head of all fighting technique? Not by a freaking longshot.
As for the so called beautiful timing - ITS A DEMO!!! You don't have to have good timing when you know exactly what the guy is going to do, and exactly how you are going to respond! That's not timing. Its this thing actors do from time to time. Rehearsing.
Now, if you want to see an actual fighter use this technique in an actual fight against an actual resisting opponent, check out this video, at one minute in. (Its my first time trying to embed, so it may not work).
Saenchai Highlight - YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=
Don't be fooled by my low post count. I have been training, actually training, martial arts longer than I have been posting on the internet. I am not an expert by any stretch of the imagination, I'm a relative beginner in fact, but I like to think I know good from bad. I just don't like to contribute to a discussion unless I feel I can add something useful. So just because I have a whitebelt under my name, don't assume I don't know a little about what I'm talking about.
Looking up stuff to make a post? No. You don't see me quoting names of scholars no one actually cares about, or citing random dates. I made some very general statements coming from what I assumed was common knowledge to most people in the martial arts.
But doing a little research before a post can be a good thing. For example, in your case. You should have done some research about the history of kung fu, before stating that martial arts travelled from india to china, a theory that has been bashed up and down martial arts forums for years.
And the saenchai vid? Of course he is widely known. I'm not trying to pull out some obscure fighter. He is arguably the most famous man in muay thai, and this is A STRIKING FORUM! Of course you have heard of him! I just wanted you to see good technique, since your hard on for this kung fu vid tells me you don't know what that is.
And for the last time, I meant no disrespect to the martial art. Just its poorer practitioners in the video, who arguably have some amazing skill. It just happens to be skill in gymnastics, more so than fighting.