Should Anderson Silva retire if he loses without controversy/clean to Uriah Hall?

[John Wick]

Anderson is 0-3-1 his last 4 fights. However, all 4 fights had some controversy. With that said, if he loses via TKO or unanimous decision without controversy against Uriah Hall should he retire?

 

[mjfan23]

Fight GSP then retire

 

[MayhemMonkey]

only if he wants to, but Id just want him to fight fun fights for the fans..... not young contenders like Uriah Hall

 

[snw10mm]

Up to him.
He's not in his prime but still dangerous.

 

[FrontNakedChoke]

I believe that Hall will KO Anderson, but there will still be interesting fights for him if he sticks around.

 

[Drake]

Would you mind telling me what the controversy was in those first two losses?


Anyways...yes he should.

 

[KONE]

Depends how he loses. If it's KO, I lean on yes.

If boring sparring-esque decision, give him one more fight and hope he goes out on a win.

 

[Bronson]

Anderson should have retired right after Stephan Bonnar. It would have been perfect.

 

[MCMXCIX]

If Hall wins in any way....i'm going to stop watching MMA forever. No joke.

 

[DaveHilly]

I just think that Anderson's chin is gone. I don't wanna see him get knocked out by fringe top 15 guys like Hall.. I know he doesn't owe the fans anything, but I don't want him to throw his legacy away on people like Uriah Hall.

 

[bigeastgi43]

Anderson is 0-3-1 his last 4 fights. However, all 4 fights had some controversy. With that said, if he loses via TKO or unanimous decision without controversy against Uriah Hall should he retire?

Only if he gets beat up.

 

[CostumedExtrmst]

Nope. I want him to gouge the shady UFC for as much as he can, so long as he has his faculties

 

[Gabe]

Yes.

 

[NightwingBJJ]

Depends how he loses. If it's KO, I lean on yes.

If boring sparring-esque decision, give him one more fight and hope he goes out on a win.

Same. If he gets knocked into the "Shadow Realm" as you would say, then its time to be Big Bossed.

 

[bigeastgi43]

Would you mind telling me what the controversy was in those first two losses?


Anyways...yes he should.

There was controversy in the second lost and the two fights after that.

 

[dredd57]

I just think that Anderson's chin is gone. I don't wanna see him get knocked out by fringe top 15 guys like Hall.. I know he doesn't owe the fans anything, but I don't want him to throw his legacy away on people like Uriah Hall.

This is kind of my thinking. Its hard seeing legends on 3 or 4 fight losing streaks at the end of their career. Jens Pulver comes to mind.

 

[cade187]

As a huge Anderson fan, I hope he wins and retires.

 

[DontWaitUp]

Anderson is 0-3-1 his last 4 fights. However, all 4 fights had some controversy. With that said, if he loses via TKO or unanimous decision without controversy against Uriah Hall should he retire?

Should he? Maybe. Do I want him to? Hell no.

 

[gevoudane]

Id say keep him around and book him for fun fights if he wants.

 

[MachidaNo1Fan]

Absolutely.