Serra/GSP or Cain/JDS?

[TeamDuffee]

idk judging by the fighters condition after the fight, JDS took a much worse beating

 

[mmagoat]

Serra's win was a fluke. JDS' win happened because Cain had ring rust and had a bad gameplan. Apples and oranges.

 

[OffMyMeds]

meh

 

[Schmogun**]

Really really really good thread. I like the comparison of a five round fight to a fight that was stopped because someone's guts were being rearranged.

 

[Dookieshoes**]

GSP finished Matt Serra in their second fight. No comparison.

 

[Bear Man]

Because Serra got finished early in the second by knees to the body.

 

[TeamDuffee]

But Serra took more punishment and JDS is a much better fighter