Movies Requiem for a Dream vs. Memento - Which is the better film?

Which is the better film?


  • Total voters
    55

Takes Two To Tango

The one who doesn't fall, doesn't stand up.
Platinum Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2010
Messages
37,028
Reaction score
50,447
Thought these two films would match each other well. Both were also released in the same year 2000.

Requiem for a Dream (Plot Summary):

Sara Goldfarb (Ellen Burstyn) is a retired widow, living in a small apartment. She spends most of her time watching TV, especially a particular self-help show. She has delusions of rising above her current dull existence by being a guest on that show.

Her son, Harry (Jared Leto) is a junkie but along with his friend Tyrone (Marlon Wayans) has visions of making it big by becoming a drug dealer. Harry's girlfriend Marion (Jennifer Connelly) could be fashion designer or artist but is swept along in Harry's drug-centric world.

Meanwhile Sara has developed an addiction of her own. She desperately wants to lose weight and so goes on a crash course involving popping pills, pills which turn out to be very addictive and harmful to her mental state.

Memento (Plot Summary):

A memory inside a memory, Memento is a complicated head spinning adventure. Leonard is determined to avenge his wife's murder. However, unable to remember anything that happens day-to-day due to a condition he sustained, short term memory loss, he has to write himself note after note that still don't mean anything after he falls asleep.

The film goes back in time to reveal each little bit of the puzzle as he tries to find out the person who killed his wife and makes the audience feel just as confused as he is. The narrative closely follows a phone call Pearce has in which he talks about Sammy Jankis a former client of his who he believed had the same condition.

The film takes an unexpected twist as the two characters have a lot more in common than is initially put across.








 
CMTlZx.gif
 
Requiem has some amazing and powerful scenes but overall not that great a film. I think Memento is better crafted and one of Nolan's best
 
Somehow I felt Memento was disturbing. I did not feel that for the movie nor book with Requiem.
 
Both really solid movies around the same time

Memento wins it for me. Requiem is a good movie but just bums me out
 
Both are great. My vote goes to Memento based on re-watchability. Requiem is just so bleak. I've only watched it maybe 3 times. Woof, no hope at all in that film.
 
Both are great films I guess but both are depressing to view.. wouldn't re watch either. Life is depressing enough
 
Just remembered memento recently and my girlfriend hasn't seen it, we'll watch it soon.

I didn't love requiem. I was youjg when I watched it but it seemed sort of pointlessly bleak or something. Mightbwaych that again too if my girlfriend hasn't seen it and wants to watch it.

Requiem was like an edgier, not-funny trainspotting
 
Hmmm...Memento has a decent lead in this. Interesting.
 
Back
Top