REALLY? JBJ IS STILL #1 P4P? WTF?!?!

[Koro_11]

Pound 4 pound is fictional and fantasy world.

Stipe Miocic is the #1 fighter in the world, the rest are just divisional champs, and Jones is not even that anymore.

 

[dim_]

Hes not #1

/thread

 

[rearnakedchoke]

Until he's officially suspended, he's still #1.

This. Like it or not, his case is still pending. If he is deemed not responsible for his negative test, well why should he be removed from the list.

 

[Me&MrJones]

Fuck P4P #1 he's the GOAT.

 

[Unbanned_unreformed]

You're free to believe that if you'd like, but I tend to believe that the fighters who are actually able to fight would be qualified for that title while those who can't fight would not be qualified for that title.

How long did he get banned for?

 

[chinarice]

Shogun was not in his prime, he had just barely beat Colman before he beat Machida.

His defense run was impressive, but is meaningless because he popped for roid's.

Andy gets somewhat of a free pass because most of the guys he fought were also on the Juice, Jon is the only LHW in all his defenses that popped, and it's not like he dominated in all his wins either.

If Jones doesn't get a pass, neither does Silva. That is absurd logic to say one is ok but the other is not.

 

[WinZip]

How long did he get banned for?

Ban hasn't been issued yet (just the temp NSAC suspension) but he's facing a minimum of 2 years out, or 4 years if USADA decides to consider it a compound failure (since he was found to have 2 different banned substances in his system).

 

[chinarice]

Pound 4 pound is fictional and fantasy world.

Stipe Miocic is the #1 fighter in the world, the rest are just divisional champs, and Jones is not even that anymore.

I agree. P4P is by far the most lame thing in combat sports. It is totally created to discredit bigger fighters and overvalue everything about smaller fighters.

 

[Etherized]

if you don't like him its because you are racist

 

[MuddyFugger]

Cheaters shouldn't be ranked at all. They cheated to get there.

 

[El Fernas]

You're free to believe that if you'd like, but I tend to believe that the fighters who are actually able to fight would be qualified for that title while those who can't fight would not be qualified for that title.

So lets say, a fighter that is retired cant be the GOAT? Retired, suspended, doesnt change a thing, he was the GOAT before all that stuff, GOAT its not an active fighters ranking, hence the OAT part.

 

[WinZip]

So lets say, a fighter that is retired cant be the GOAT? Retired, suspended, doesnt change a thing, he was the GOAT before all that stuff, GOAT its not an active fighters ranking, hence the OAT part.

No, a fighter that's retired can't be considered the current #1 P4P fighter since, you know, they're not actively fighting.

And no, he wasn't the GOAT before his suspension. Thanks for trying.

 

[WinZip]

Hes not #1

/thread

aaaaaaaaand @dimspace ends it.
There ya go.

 

[bjpenngoat]

what the fuck does his bad behavior outside the cage have to do with his in cage dominance. Is Lawrence Taylor a saint? Dude fucked 15 year old prostitutes and did coke for 30 years but he is still considered the best LB of all time.

 

[$uicideboy$]

read my thread ts

http://forums.sherdog.com/threads/why-jon-is-still-the-goat.3294835/

 

[Stoic]

Shogun just beating an undefeated Machida for the title (arguably twice) is out of his prime and a 40 year old Anderson Silva coming off an insane injury popping is comparable to a 29 year old Jones popping. Sherdog never fails to disappoint.

 

[HockeyBjj]

Because he is still the best fighter on the UFC's roster

He is also the dumbest

 

[Recounter]

P4P means they are all equal in size.

JBJ relies on his height and reach so much, he shouldn't even be in p4p list.

Aside from all his BS behavior inside or outside octagon, his skills are pretty average.

 

[jonathan274]

How is this realistic? Yes he never lost bla bla bla. How many times does this guy have to fuck up for the MMA world to realize he don't give a fuck? He should not be included in any of this at all!

TS - watch this video carefully. Listen. Now, hit that repeat button. Come back to us after 3 hours and tell us how you really feel.

 

[datfnguy]

How is this realistic? Yes he never lost bla bla bla. How many times does this guy have to fuck up for the MMA world to realize he don't give a fuck? He should not be included in any of this at all!

You know how schools have zero tolerance for violence and people always say shit like nobody wins in a fight? Well think of it this way... fighters are not role models they are fighters. Why does a fucking professional fighter need to have a clean image?