Rank your top 10 GOAT list

[riitzni]

GSP ~ Fedor = Andy

Jones in three years will pass all of them.

 

[Taric]

Lol. If he was so talented, he wouldn't have lost so many times

Penn is 11-3 at LW. 11-4 if you wanna include Edgar/Penn 3 as well.

Be real son.

 

[jlazer]

Penn is 11-3 at LW. 11-4 if you wanna include Edgar/Penn 3 as well.

Be real son.

And his best win at lw was who, Kenny Florian? You know how many people have better resumes than that??

11-3 isn't that impressive

 

[Greco_Wiz]

Top 5 are easy...

GSP, Jones, Andy, Aldo, and Fedor. Order debatable, list is not.

The next 5 are harder...

Henderson, Hughes, MM, Nog and Edgar.

Honorable mention to Cruz, Rousey (yes Srs), and Randy. If Cruz had stayed healthy he'd easily be a top 5 goat.

 

[Taric]

And his best win at lw was who, Kenny Florian? You know how many people have better resumes than that??

11-3 isn't that impressive

Gomi is an amazing win. To not mention it is ludicrous lol

 

[RockyLockridge]

Here we go with the elitist "Tuffers suck" crap. The show has produce a lot of crappy fighters for sure, but it has also produce champions (Forrest, Evans, Dillashaw) as well as perennial top contenders (Florian, Bisping, Maynard, Dodson, etc.).

I don't really believe tufers are crap or whatever some of my favourite fighters are tuffers.

but It's an easy way to detract, Sanchez and Florian were both pretty green

 

[SocraticMethod]

I don't really believe tufers are crap or whatever some of my favourite fighters are tuffers.

but It's an easy way to detract, Sanchez and Florian were both pretty green

Diego was 21-2 when he fought Penn. I guess you could argue that Florian was "pretty green" with only 14 fights (11-3) when he fought Penn, but he was on a 6-fight win streak and it was his second time going for a title.

 

[Tactitus]

1. Silva
2. Fedor
3. Jones
4. GSP
5. Aldo

 

[RABBITBELLI]

1. Anderson
2. Fedor
3. BJ
4. Wand
5. Aldo
6. Jon Jones
7. GSP
8. Randy
9. Rickson Gracie
10. Big Nog

 

[Shotokan36]

Silva,GSP,Jones,Fedor, Penn, Hughes,Aldo, Chuck, Cain, Dan Henderson

 

[mr bandwagon]

Top four (in order):

Fedor
GSP
Jones
Anderson

The rest are too hard to rank

 

[Herbal Dean]

Fedor
GSP
Anderson
Don't care x 7

 

[Kingfarthur]

The top 10, in tiers.

The best ever

1. Fedor
2. Jon Jones

The Legends

3. GSP
4. Anderson Silva
5. Jose Aldo

The great but flawed

6. Big Nog
7. Dan Henderson
8. Demetrious Johnson
9. Cain Velasquez
10. Frank Shamrock

 

[Starman]

Fedor
GSP
Silva

Sakuraba
Gracie
Shamrock (Frank)

Hughes
Penn

Jones
Aldo

 

[Redapplejuice]

1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Jones
4. Anderson
5. Aldo
6. Hughes
7. Wanderlei
8. Ronda
9. Frankie Edgar
10.Big Nog

 

[jlazer]

Penn is 11-3 at LW. 11-4 if you wanna include Edgar/Penn 3 as well.

Be real son.

And his best win at lw was who, Kenny Florian? You know how many people have better resumes than that? 11-3 isn't that impressive

 

[Hendo101]

Anderson Silva
Fedor Emelanenko
Jon Jones
Georges St-Pierre
BJ Penn
Jose Aldo
Matt Hughes
Minotauro Nogueira
Dan Henderson
Vitor Belfort

 

[tuco1808]

Fedor
Gsp
Anderson
Hendo
Couture
Matt hughes
Big nog
Bj
Wandy
Shogun

Too soon to rank aldo, jbj etc

Honourable shout to the pioneers royce, bas, shamrock x 2

 

[Edsonbarboza1]

all of the McGregor clan that fought in the 17 the century in the scottish highlands,9 of them and conor as #1

 

[epsilon]

1. Fedor
2. GSP
3. Jones
4. ROyce Gracie
5. Anderson Silva
5. ALdo
6. Cro-cop
7. Nogueira
9. Wanderei SIlva
9. Velasquez
10. Don Fyre for the pinch

Special price : BAs Rutten and Rickson Gracie .