Rank these careers in order 1-6

[Rampage_Jackson]

or don't, its your life. but you clicked so you might as well rank them

Couture
Chuck
Wanderei
Shogun
Henderson
Rampage

I really feel like 205 is the hardest to rank GOATs after Jones obviously. You could really take it any way you wanted just curious to see what the fellas think

 

[Randy Fandy Fo Fanders]

Hi TS, I don’t have time to do this right now, but maybe later when I’m free?

Thanks for understanding

Xoxo

 

[Rampage_Jackson]

Hi TS, I don’t have time to do this right now, but maybe later when I’m free?

Thanks for understanding

Xoxo

This really grinds my gears but I'll try to take it in stride

 

[2004 account]

6.Couture
5.Chuck
4.Wanderei
3.Shogun
2.Henderson
1.Rampage

 

[Azure]

1) Henderson
2) Couture
3) Chuck
4) Wanderei
5) Rampage
6) Shogun

 

[Kowboy On Sherdog]

1. Hendo ( Most Belts )
2. Wanderlei ( Pride Champ / Longest Win Streak )
3. Shogun ( Pride GP / UFC Champ )
4. Randy ( UFC 205 / Heavyweight Champ )
5. Rampage ( UFC 205 Champ )
6. Chuck ( UFC 205 Champ )

Hell... I could rearrange this list over and over

 

[Mammothman]

There is no correct answer for this, they are all very close with great ups and downs.

 

[ChrisBenoit]

1. Randy
2. Hendo
3. Shogun
4. Rampage
5. Chuck
6. Wand

All close though

 

[JoeRowe]

1. Randy
2. Chuck
3. Hendo
4. Shogun
5. Rampage
6. Wand

 

[Rampage_Jackson]

6.Couture
5.Chuck
4.Wanderei
3.Shogun
2.Henderson
1.Rampage

Was discussing this with one of the lads and he was disgusted I had Randy 6th. Glad I'm not crazy. Or at least we are crazy together.

 

[Rampage_Jackson]

1. Hendo ( Most Belts )
2. Wanderlei ( Pride Champ / Longest Win Streak )
3. Shogun ( Pride GP / UFC Champ )
4. Randy ( UFC 205 / Heavyweight Champ )
5. Rampage ( UFC 205 Champ )
6. Chuck ( UFC 205 Champ )

Hell... I could rearrange this list over and over

Its really tough to separate them I found it interesting. I could see arguments for all

 

[Croton]

1. Randy. Multiple time champion in two different divisions. Oldest champion to hold a belt by a long shot and will likely hold that record for a long time.

2. Hendo. Double pride champ. Strikeforce champ. Fought the baddest anywhere and anytime.

3. Shogun. Pride GP and UFC champ. Ended the Machida era. Could have been a GOAT if not for all his injuries

4. Wanderlei. Had a very great career in pride. Huge win streak and fought the baddest of the bad.

5. Chuck. One of the most feared fighters in the UFC back in his prime. Defended his belt four times in the UFC

6. Rampage. Exciting fighter, has some great wins against a couple of fighters on this list even. Won the UFC belt. Didn't manage too many defenses though.

 

[Typrune Goatley]

There is no correct answer for this, they are all very close with great ups and downs.

Yes, and all their careers and legacies basically hinge on each other because they all fought each other in big fights.

Chuck fought Rampage 2x, Wanderlei, Randy 3x, Shogun

Hendo fought Wand 2x, Shogun 2x, and Rampage

Shogun fought Rampage, Chuck, Hendo 2x

Wanderlei fought Rampage 4x, Chuck, Hendo 2x

Randy only fought Chuck


I can't rank them. It's like picking your favorite child. They were all so great and all were legendary champions. I will say Wand is a global icon, Randy also won the Heavyweight title, Rampage beat most of them head to head, Chuck was most famous in America, Chuck and Wand had the best title reigns, Hendo is the most decorated as he has won some huge tournaments and won in 3 weight classes and probably has the best resume out of any fighter, Shogun had the best single year and and was a PRIDE GP Champ and still became UFC Champ while going through major injuries and surgeries.

Honestly, they are all about equal. On all time P4P list though, Hendo would rank the highest so maybe he is the correct answer.

 

[Mammothman]

Yes, and all their careers and legacies basically hinge on each other because they all fought each other in big fights.

Chuck fought Rampage 2x, Wanderlei, Randy 3x, Shogun

Hendo fought Wand 2x, Shogun 2x, and Rampage

Shogun fought Rampage, Chuck, Hendo 2x

Wanderlei fought Rampage 4x, Chuck, Hendo 2x

Randy only fought Chuck


I can't rank them. It's like picking your favorite child. They were all so great and all were legendary champions. I will say Wand is a global icon, Randy also won the Heavyweight title, Rampage beat most of them head to head, Chuck was most famous in America, Chuck and Wand had the best title reigns, Hendo is the most decorated as he has won some huge tournaments and won in 3 weight classes and probably has the best resume out of any fighter, Shogun had the best single year and and was a PRIDE GP Champ and still became UFC Champ while going through major injuries and surgeries.

Honestly, they are all about equal. On all time P4P list though, Hendo would rank the highest so maybe he is the correct answer.

Well said, its wholesome how they basically helped each other to build their legacies.

I also agree, Hendo most likely have the most stacked resume ever.

 

[Khaosan]

It was a hell of a time to be a fan when they were all active in their primes.

 

[Egészségére!]

Henderson

 

[dipstickjimmy]

1. Hendo ( Most Belts )
2. Wanderlei ( Pride Champ / Longest Win Streak )
3. Shogun ( Pride GP / UFC Champ )
4. Randy ( UFC 205 / Heavyweight Champ )
5. Rampage ( UFC 205 Champ )
6. Chuck ( UFC 205 Champ )

Hell... I could rearrange this list over and over

Just for arguments sake how does Hendo have more belts? Pride x 2 and Strikeforce x2 but is that really more than Randy winning the UFC HW title 3x and LHW 2x?

I would have Randy above Hendo but as you said you could shuffle these names over and over.

 

[Fight Professor]

Randy - 3x UFC Heavyweight Champion, 2x Light Heavyweight Champion, mainstream
Dan - PRIDE WW and MW champ + Strikeforce champ
Shogun - UFC and PRIDE grand prix champ
Chuck - UFC LW champ, the most mainstream
Wand - Pride champ, long streak
Rampage - UFC LW champ

 

[Superzorro]

1. Randy. Multiple time champion in two different divisions. Oldest champion to hold a belt by a long shot and will likely hold that record for a long time.

2. Hendo. Double pride champ. Strikeforce champ. Fought the baddest anywhere and anytime.

3. Shogun. Pride GP and UFC champ. Ended the Machida era. Could have been a GOAT if not for all his injuries

4. Wanderlei. Had a very great career in pride. Huge win streak and fought the baddest of the bad.

5. Chuck. One of the most feared fighters in the UFC back in his prime. Defended his belt four times in the UFC

6. Rampage. Exciting fighter, has some great wins against a couple of fighters on this list even. Won the UFC belt. Didn't manage too many defenses though.

This one right here.

 

[BowserJr]

or don't, its your life. but you clicked so you might as well rank them

Couture
Chuck
Wanderei
Shogun
Henderson
Rampage

I really feel like 205 is the hardest to rank GOATs after Jones obviously. You could really take it any way you wanted just curious to see what the fellas think

Careerwise. Strictly 205

Chuck
Randy
Wanderlei
Shogun
Rampage
Hendo

Resume
Rampage
Shogun
Chuck
Wanderlei
Randy
Hendo

Not strictly 205 it all changes since Hendo and Randy did very well in multiple weights. They'd me much higher for sure