Why does DC go above Stipe?
Stipe has had two rematches. The first JDS he lost a decision, the second he TKOd him in the first...having eliminated the Cain-inspired wrestling that tired him the previous time and cutting straight to the chase. The first Cormier he lost via 1st round KO, the second he wins by TKO in the 4th...by means of a sudden in-game shift in strategy.
Cormier has had three rematches. The first Jones fight he lost to a decision, the second he got KOd (later overturned to NC)...though I'll admit he did look sharper in the 2nd fight. The first Anthony Johnson fight he won by RNC, the 2nd fight the same...but with Rumble being derpier than before, fighting so stupidly his own coaches abandoned him. The 1st Miocic fight he wins with a first round knockout, the second he loses by TKO...having roundly disregarded his corner's coaching to their evident exasperation.
So to recap: Stipe has had a far better outcome when he rematches, DC has had at best the same but more often worse outcomes. And it's Stipe that gets placed last?