Prime Schaub vs. Modern Day Brock - who takes it?

[OneToeKO]

I give the edge to Schaub. Before his chin gave out he was an absolute killer with A level athleticism.

This also assumes Brock isn’t juiced btw.

 

[tithas]

brock. Schuab has no TD defense and no chin.

 

[Superman Elbow]

Weird face off, but Schaub.

 

[Threetrees]

brock. Schuab has no TD defense and no chin.

wrong
One of the things Prime Schaub did best was TDD

he would fuck Brock

 

[Mysterio]

Brock. Get real.

 

[JoeyJoeJoeJr]

we dont know what brock is today, since he hasnt fought in a long time. if hes anything like the guy who fought hunt, he would win

 

[tithas]

wrong
One of the things Prime Schaub did best was TDD

he would fuck Brock

Against which elite wrestler again??

 

[Workaholic]

I think you'd be surprised

 

[613]

Brock easy

 

[Captain Herb]

Brock would destroy Brendan. This is a dumb thread.

 

[Threetrees]

Against which elite wrestler again??

Do it mather tho
Schaub has been taken down like three times in his career

 

[613]

I think you'd be surprised

No dude, I think you'd be surprised

 

[Mixfight]

Schaub sux and was always a bum with a glass chin. Brock would have violated him at any point of their careers.

 

[Sapp]

Prime Schaub KOs Fedor and Jones on the same night.

 

[tithas]

Do it mather tho
Schaub has been taken down like three times in his career

Yes it 100% matters. Its easy to defend takedowns form 230lb striker crocop, 580 year old nog (who KOed scooba) and rothwell. Its another thing to defend against a 290 lb national champion who got everyone down including Cain (couldn't hold him down though).

 

[Threetrees]

Yes it 100% matters. Its easy to defend takedowns form 230lb striker crocop, 580 year old nog (who KOed scooba) and rothwell. Its another thing to defend against a 290 lb national champion who got everyone down including Cain (couldn't hold him down though).

you said that he has no TD defense
that's nonsense and you have zero basis for that comment

I said that's among the things he did best
that's accurate, based on what he's done

My statement about him fucking Brock was separate from the above commentary

so again

do it matter tho

 

[MMA_AZ]

Blonde on blonde crime

 

[Flboycanscrap2]

Schaub was never that good at anything and is a notorious panic fighter. His best showings were against CC and GG who have no wrestling and weak chins.

Even Hunt Brock takes Schaub down and TKO's him.

 

[Rum]

Schaub starches no-roids Brock with ease.

 

[FreddieRoachsVoice]

The notion that Schaub's chin suddenly "gave out" is misguided considering he had been KO'd various times throughout his career (even by Nog who was never a power puncher) and not just a bunch of times at the end. Chuck's chin was once great but "gave out".... Schaub never had a good chin.

That being said, this isn't a ridiculous fight and Schaub was a decent fighter in his day. To answer your question, I'd still have to say Brock via TKO. Schaub was fast but I doubt he's faster than Brock and I've never seen Schaub face a decent enough wrestler to give me the confidence that he could stop the takedown. If Brock got on top of him once, which I think he would, one or 2 of those giant hammerfists would easily put out Schaub's lights.

Brock via TKO