Penn vs Edgar

[Charliebumfluff]

Why is this fight happening I'm confused, so many better fights for both, and it's not really a worthy trilogy if Edgar won both

 

[cleber]

bj asked for it

the fact that the fight takes place at 145 makes it interesting

many people (including me) think BJ will do better at lower weight classes

 

[Perrichet]

BJ Penn wants to get beat up again.

I'm all for it

 

[Task]

BJ asked for it.

Frankie agreed.

.... is normal.

I don't get the objection?

They also both got to do TUF off it, so that's a plus point in ratings for the show (their history) and publicity for the fight.

 

[Charliebumfluff]

bj asked for it

the fact that the fight takes place at 145 makes it interesting

many people (including me) think BJ will do better at lower weight classes

Yeah true, I forgot about the change of weight, makes it more interesting

 

[Rvd Slmr]

the fact that the fight takes place at 145 makes it interesting

many people (including me) think BJ will do better at lower weight classes

Yeah true, I forgot about the change of weight, makes it more interesting

I strongly disagree, it would only make sense if Edgar was bigger than Penn and it's clearly not the case.

 

[ALAN PARTRIDGE]

dont be confused son

 

[Spycho]

Rooting for Penn but I think Frankie has this. I like how respectful they are towards eachother on TUF. So much better than all that fake WWF shit between coaches and then stinking the place up or fights never materialising. I'm hoping for a good scrap.

 

[BuffaloEmperor]

Frankie's contact states he can only fight for championships or rematchs.

 

[Hanri]

They should be 1-1

 

[sdaccount]

What everyone else said. It also gives the UFC a small chance to infuse BJ against a named 145'er if he beats Edgar.

 

[FinBJJ]

BJ wanted to avenge his losses. Frankie was up for it. I don't see the problem.

Should be a good one.

 

[spinitch]

BJ wanted to avenge his losses. Frankie was up for it. I don't see the problem.

Should be a good one.

This. Both well known and should be able to bring in some viewers.

I am looking fwd to it, much more than most other bouts. It is a classic.

 

[Rhood]

Because Ortiz/Shamrock III happened, and so shall this fight.

 

[Tang Hermit]

I`m pumped for this fight! I`m rooting for B.J. to finish Frankie sometime before the 3rd is over. Nothing against Frankie I got mad respect for him! I`m just a blind B.J. nutthugger & glad to see him back. I`m also excited to see this fight at 145. I`m just happy B.J. is back & not fighting at 170.