P4P, which GOAT’s skill set would be the toughest stylistic matchup to your favorite GOAT?

[Dozer .]

The 6 GOATs of MMA are Aldo, Anderson, Fedor, Jones, DJ, GSP.

My favorite GOAT is Aldo.

P4P, I think prime Anderson’s skill set would be prime Aldo’s toughest stylistic match up.

Aldo’s skill set matches up very well against the skill sets’ of GSP, Jones, and DJ.

Who’s your favorite GOAT and who is their toughest match up skill wise?

We are assuming that all GOATs are in their prime and we are looking at skill sets only, so size difference wouldn’t be an issue.

 

[Magx951]

Idk TS, how about we debate superheroes and other fictional fights as well?

 

[Arqueto]

Motivated BJ Penn is my favorite GOAT.

He has no bad matchups.

 

[NotA CleverName]

Keith Hackney..

Best Skill Set ,
He is the GOAT of the Nut Punch

 

[Dreago]

I second Hackney.

 

[ImNotSurpisedDonks!]

LeL @ Aldo being GOAT. He is still in his prime, homie, and Conor and Max melted him; that means he ain't even the best all time at 45. Time to drop the nostalgia, move on and come back to reality. He was great fighter, great like Mighty Mouse tho and just competed in a shallow undeveloped division against undersized, old, young and tailor made match ups. I'd be shocked if any version of Aldo beat Zabit, Ortega, Max or Conor.

 

[TIMELESS TRUTH]

 

[KingBeef]

I think the toughest matchup for Jones would be an elite grappler with one punch KO power(Rumble-like).

 

[Erocthadon]

Prime Anderson Silva would murk all those bums

 

[3sumrock]

DJ would be a nightmare for other goats p4p
gsp p4p would be a nightmare for silva
jones would destroy fedor
aldo p4p would be a nightmare for jones.

 

[jaredmc16]

Quit calling DJ A GOAT

 

[Takamine86]

Ronda Rousey under the right circumstances.

Those circumstances being every man paralyzed from the neck down and she doesn't have to fight Matt Hamill.

 

[Goon Dog]

View attachment 368195

Golden Eagle FTW

 

[Mebetter]

I think the toughest matchup for Jones would be an elite grappler with one punch KO power(Rumble-like).

That’s Glover, Bader, and maybe DC

 

[KingBeef]

That’s Glover, Bader, and maybe DC

None of those guys have Rumble KO power.

 

[Perrichet]

The 6 GOATs of MMA are Aldo, Anderson, Fedor, Jones, DJ, GSP.

My favorite GOAT is Aldo.

P4P, I think prime Anderson’s skill set would be prime Aldo’s toughest stylistic match up.

Aldo’s skill set matches up very well against the skill sets’ of GSP, Jones, and DJ.

Who’s your favorite GOAT and who is their toughest match up skill wise?

We are assuming that all GOATs are in their prime and we are looking at skill sets only, so size difference wouldn’t be an issue.

Yeah. Aldo gets destroyed by better strikers. See him vs Conor and Max X2

Anderson would lose to Jones, GSP and DJ.

 

[Mebetter]

None of those guys have Rumble KO power.

Because nobody at LHW and below has Rumble power he is an anomaly. That being said Glover and Bader still have one punch ko power

 

[KingBeef]

Because nobody at LHW and below has Rumble power he is an anomaly

That was my point.

 

[Agent Mulder's Hair]

Fedor's toughest stylistic matchup imo would be prime Randy Couture. Possibly prime BJ Penn

 

[AC1D1K]

nice thread. my fav goat is wonderboy, and twoodz beat him so... whoever can beat twoodz and wboy would be the toughest. ( i dont think that person even exists)