I definitely agree that Max getting the immediate rematch has hurt him in the long run and put him in this weird position like Aldo before him, and Wonderboy at 170, but 3 title defenses and a decision loss still holds more merit than 1 title defense and a 1st round KO defeat, all in all I agree though, and this isn't about being a Max fan haha, I get that me being a Fan of him makes it seem that I'm impartial, but that's not always the case. Of all the Max fans on this forum, I argued the least about his decision loss in the Volkanovski rematch, scoring of the 1st 2 rounds aside, he didn't do enough to win 3 4, and 5. As for Title Defenses, 3 isn't exactly knocking down the doors for Goat Candidate I agree, but it's also not easy to accomplish for most UFC Champions, and when it comes to the Featherweight division, he holds the 2nd most title defenses. With that said, I wasn't really all that crazy about the rematch either, but I wasn't complaining, looking at the aftermath and yeah there's really not much to be happy about when we look at how things are playing out as a result.
I'm 100% Bias against Grandpa Giga I'll give you that one lol, once people start talking about people older than Max being "Prospects" and "Future Champions" I just become unimpressed, like he just beat aging Edson Barboza and Cub Swanson, he's gonna need to do a LOT more than that to convince me he's this "Heir" to the FW Championship, and with fighters like Volkanovski, and Max sitting at the top, him and his fans can shill with that shit. I'm not denying his striking pedigree and lethality he possesses on the feet, but I feel he's getting some..."undeserved" hype.
As for certain fighters holding onto their rankings, it blew my mind to that Yair still managed to hold onto his ranking that long, but that goes back to the UFC and their plans to fast track Zabit up the rankings as they knew he would be the easiest "Ranked" opponent to beat. Seems were pretty much on the same page about the UFC booking the FW Division to shit though, I might have misread earlier so I apologize. The more I think about it, the more I agree, just perhaps read into it the wrong way earlier. As for Ortega losing his ranking, I do believe he was trying to get fights scheduled, I could be wrong, but he was just injury prone for the most part hence why it took him 2 years.