yetanother
Im not sure I can agree with you. If your statement was true, then the same has to be true that only Michael Jordan or Terry Bradshaw types can be successful coaches. But we know that is not true. It would also mean that our politicans in DC are all top notch because they win re-election year after year with name reconition. But we know that anit true either. Yet some not as well know instructor as the Mendes Brothers consistently is at the top or near top year after year it seems with a small school. Bear Bryant, one of the greatest if not greatest college coaches in history zero time in the pros. Pat Riley of your Lakers didnt have a great NBA career either.
Me who knows zero about Jiu Jitsu history and my knowledge is so limited about the top people I think makes it easier for me to peel back the onion looking at a small school with a small amout of kids yet is at the top year after year. How do you explain that?
I don't have any experience with running a kids competition team so I can't really tell what makes a winning kids team.
I For adults the main reason that top level guys like the Mendes Brothers are a league beyond someone like Master Ali (is Master his real name?) as instructors is that they have the technical knowledge.
The reason the Mendes brother have won so many titles isn't because they are freak athletes, it's because they have (re)invented a lot of the modern jiu jitsu.
You can't really teach something you don't know.
How can Master Ali teach me the "knee on belly" position if based on the youtube video I have seen of him rolling he can't do it properly?
In jiu jitsu technique is the most important factor and the top guys have >100x better technique then the average black belt.
When training with my coach (in Europe) who is a decent black belt I often have questions (and so does my coach after training 10+ years) that we don't know the answer too.
Does it matter if your kid is learning inferior jiu jitsu, most likely not if it's done just for fun.
Master Ali could be great at motivation children, teaching them respect for the opponents etc.
Is the Art of Jiu Jitsu the right place for a kid?
I can't tell having never been there.
The hero worship that seems to be done at the AOJ is a bit discouraging (Imagine a kids team being taught by Michael Jordan).