- Joined
- Dec 15, 2018
- Messages
- 7,512
- Reaction score
- 935
China probably did have styles that were once effective and they currently do in Sanda but China is huge with multiple cultures that it has absorbed over time and subjugated. It is not unique to China that in the process of one culture absorbing another they ban martial and military training and as a result the absorbed culture creates a dance style in place of a martial tradition as is the case with the shaolin temple, capoeira, and Cossak dance. It is also seems to be a pattern that martial arts created from the dance styles are bullshido when they are created with a compliant training partner like in Hopak and wing chun.I don’t care about this , im talking about bs story prior to this nonsense. I don’t train in a TMA or sport . I do have a respect for TMA . Yes China did train train for combat prior to ww2. And Kung fu held full contact matches Lei tai .
Wrestling has a long history in the united states and was more commonly practiced prior to television becoming widespread. They used to just call it playing and like any game that is passed down it had rules and moves that came along with it. The thing about it was it was it didn't allude to any sort of mystical nonsense or promote itself as a killing art reserved for a special class of people as was the case for martial traditions in feudal societies. It didn't have to because it worked and the guys that were really good at it would travel around and prove it worked on the carnival circuit back in the day with open challenges.
The thing about western society is we have been critiquing chivalry since at least the publication of Don Quixote in 1605. Yes, over 400 years ago! the Japanese equivalent to chivalry being Bushido or whatever to which Martial traditions were married with along with a specialized class of citizenry which only ended in Japan with the preservation of Jui Jitsu via the Kodokan less than 150 years ago. Because of that a martial tradition like wrestling doesn't come prepackaged with a bunch mystical ideological crap justifying a socially stratified society which I doubt you will find in Judo either. For some ignorant reason people seem to make the association between martial art and mystical ideological crap.
What actually ends up happening in practice though is the TMA guys that fetishize east Asian martial arts systems end up actually being the ones that are insensitive judgmental, and ignorant of western martial traditions because they lack the mystical pseudo religious aura that has come to be associated with martial arts.