MW Top 10 after yesturday

Heaviside said:
The division shifting is unfortunate, but it can really ruin things, Lw rankings are nearly impossible with all of Bjs shannigans. I would think Vitor could probably beat a lot of mws, him vs machida would be a great fight.
Click to expand...

It's kind of amazing that Machida vs Vitor hasn't happened yet.

DC and Dan probably screw with your rankings systems pretty good!
 
Heaviside said:
Heres a few changes to the top 10 after yesturday.
1 Chris Weidman
2 Anderson Silva
3 Ronaldo Souza
4 CB Dollaway
5 Francis Carmont
6 Luke Rockhold
7 Constantinos Philippou
8 Lyoto Machida
9 Gegard Mousasi
10 Mark Munoz
Click to expand...

Your list is probably the worst I've ever seen, and that really is saying something!!
 
Heaviside said:
Like I've said, they're not based on my opinion, therefore they're not really my rankings. I have simply, out of curiousity, figured them out. If you are interested I have the rankings for other divisions (not all, some of the lower weight classes are not well-established enough) if you would like to see them.
Click to expand...

The only way someone could come up with the shitty list you have provided is to put names into a generator and let it scramble em up.


No need to see anything else from you.
 
icex48x said:
The only way someone could come up with the shitty list you have provided is to put names into a generator and let it scramble em up.


No need to see anything else from you.
Click to expand...

How would you derive an objective way to determine rankings?
 
nogdog said:
imo...

Champion: Chris Weidman
1. Anderson Silva
2. Lyoto Machida
3. Vitor Belfort
4. Jacare
5. Gegard Mousasi
6. Luke Rockhold
7. Tim Kennedy
8. Michael Bisping
9. Yoel Romero
10. CB Dollaway
Click to expand...

okay this seems reasonable
 
Heaviside said:
Heres a few changes to the top 10 after yesturday.
1 Chris Weidman
2 Anderson Silva
3 Ronaldo Souza
4 CB Dollaway
5 Francis Carmont
6 Luke Rockhold
7 Constantinos Philippou
8 Lyoto Machida
9 Gegard Mousasi
10 Mark Munoz
Click to expand...


951.gif





CB Dollaway top 5 huh?
 
Heaviside said:
How would you derive an objective way to determine rankings?
Click to expand...

You have CB Dollaway at 4.

Based on a win over Carmont, who you have at 5 and that is based on a win over Philippou, who you have at 7 and that is based on a win over Boetsch who you don't even have in your top 10.


You gave these guys top spots based on ONE win, and IMO that ONE win each of them have are against fighters who shouldn't have been in the TOP 10 to begin with.

Also... LOL @ Munoz still in anyones top 10.
 
Safari Safa said:
Lol at people putting Silva in top 5 and Chael in top 10 :))) A rank should be about who is better right now. Silva would get his ass kicked by every top 5 fighter.
Click to expand...

lol at your stupidity.
 
To be somewhat fair to the TS....

Vitor actually hasn't won a fight at MW in over a year.

And more importantly why in the blue hell would anyone in their right mind have Anderson Silva ranked in the top 3?

Under no circumstances can you look that bad in your last 2 fights and be ranked that high.
 
Heaviside said:
Well fortunately Dc is now ranked at lhw with his Henderson win, and Dan has been at Lhw since Fedor and became pretty high ranked therre right away with his shogun win(who was #2 at the time). Lw has definately been the hardest, with Bjs movements and the fact that it is relatively new. Weird cuts also sucks like fitch, okami and sheilds, because then the rankings become stretched in all the different orgs. The Fitch cut has done some weird things to the ww rankings.
Click to expand...

LW is relatively new?
 
icex48x said:
You have CB Dollaway at 4.

Based on a win over Carmont, who you have at 5 and that is based on a win over Philippou, who you have at 7 and that is based on a win over Boetsch who you don't even have in your top 10.


You gave these guys top spots based on ONE win, and IMO that ONE win each of them have are against fighters who shouldn't have been in the TOP 10 to begin with.

Also... LOL @ Munoz still in anyones top 10.
Click to expand...

Boetsch has been beat out of the top 10. I think one top 10 win is greater than many outside the top 10, for example Matt Serra beat Gsp and became the #1 ww with 1 top 10 win, yet who could argue that he was the #1 ww at the time? These rankings stem from the same logic.
 
Kneeuinthenutz said:
To be somewhat fair to the TS....

Vitor actually hasn't won a fight at MW in over a year.

And more importantly why in the blue hell would anyone in their right mind have Anderson Silva ranked in the top 3?

Under no circumstances can you look that bad in your last 2 fights and be ranked that high.
Click to expand...

Did he really look that bad aside from the catastrophic stoppages?
and a gruesome leg break is a sorta weird thing to hold against a guy :D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,236,980
Messages
55,459,077
Members
174,787
Latest member
Freddie556

Share this page

Back
Top