MW GOAT, and it's not even close.

[Jose Beehive]

 

[michaelmichaelmichael90]

And he was 44, 6 years removed from being champ.
Fedor lost to Mitrione does that mean Mitrione is the goat?

I was waiting for some idiot to say "but Silva lost to Izzy!". That should show u what kind of "fan" ur talking too

 

[Kvothe_the_kingkiller]

Right now he’s where A Silva was after beating Hendo.

A Silva won his next 10 fights.

Like the other poster said, let’s talk again after 4 more successful defenses.

There is a strong (but not airtight) argument that he’s #2. I wouldn’t bother debating it either way, because #2 isn’t crazy and #3 isn’t crazy either.

 

[TheMessiah]

That's actually what makes it more embarrassing. That Silva was way past his prime and should have lost his last 8 yet the "MW Goat" couldn't finish him

 

[George Costanza]

they fought, and Silva loss.

By your logic,

Neroni Savaiinae= MW GOAT Confirmed.


Also, Mitrione beat Fedor. So.... Mitrione= HW GOAT.

 

[jojoRed]

He's not there yet but he already has better wins than Silva.

A few more defences and it becomes arguable.

 

[jojoRed]

That's actually what makes it more embarrassing. That Silva was way past his prime and should have lost his last 8 yet the "MW Goat" couldn't finish him

No it isnt.

DC couldnt finish Silva aswell, and DC is easily #2 LHW ever...

Youre basically calling Silva, garbage. You should be talking about how good Silva is still. And Silva is easily the most seasoned and elite striker Izzy has fought in the UFC...

 

[Sure Dawg]

cool, now freeze on a frame where anderson landed a punch

 

[druni]

Anderson -10 title defenses (8 finishes)

Adesanya - 2 title defenses (1 finish)

I don’t recall Israel getting submitted by undersized japanese cans with losing records.

 

[FIMN]

He's beaten off every big name

 

[TheMessiah]

No it isnt.

DC couldnt finish Silva aswell, and DC is easily #2 LHW ever...

Youre basically calling Silva, garbage. You should be talking about how good Silva is still. And Silva is easily the most seasoned and elite striker Izzy has fought in the UFC...

Im saying he isn't good right now, He's a shell of his former self. Still better reflexes at this age though than contender Paulo Costa which says a lot about the evolution of the division

 

[ColbyCovChamp]

Izzy's level of competition is far stiffer than Anderoid's

 

[Dana's Moonface]

If adesanya is mw goat, then you bet your ass that usman is ww goat

Hard to imagine usman needing to cheat to beat Bj or getting his shit pushed in by little matt serra

 

[GrayArea]

If adesanya is mw goat, then you bet your ass that usman is ww goat

Hard to imagine usman needing to cheat to beat Bj or getting his shit pushed in by little matt serra

Gsp needs to beat Serra in a trilogy match otherwise Georges will forever be tied with Serra as #2 WW behind Usman. @Sonny Qc knows this

 

[kflo]

 

[Vegeta]

Get a life ts.

 

[Sonny Qc]

Get a life ts.

 

[TheScorpionDude]

Against the number one contenders... that's it...doesn't matter who it ends up being.

The trajectory of a division can change quick so outside of Cannonier if he beats Whittaker, who knows.

Who knows how Santos will look now... dude had both of his knees destroyed

I don't think Thiago cares whether or not his knees are destroyed

 

[orca]

they fought, and Silva loss.

hey imagine 31 year old prime silva fighting 42 year old washed up adesanya. u think anyone would allow it.

 

[DarthChen731]

Needs a few years. Maybe