My bad, I meant inconsistent against against top competition. I don't put much stock in fighters who have awesome records and ran through way lesser comp in regionals or lesser orgs.
I'm looking at the UFC. he beat a bunch of mid-tier fighters. he beat Mike Kyle, then Latifi, and then Machida beat him fairly easily. Then he beats Munhoz (mid-tier again), and the gets absolutely flogged by Jacare. Then old man Hendo and Costa Phillopu (mid tier again). Then Leites(mid-tier), Hall(mid-tier), Santos(was mid-tier but came up), Vitor (washed up at the time), and then finally Weidman who was on a 2 fight losing streak.
He was clearly inconsistent when it came to fight the more elite fighters. He never fought guys like Whittaker or Yoel or Luke. The best fighter he fought was Jacare, and he got absolutely thrashed everywhere in that fight before getting finished. He didn't look like he belonged in there against Jacare.
Now he's run off to Bellator and talking shit from there? Moose is a joke.