but i didn't pick Edwards to win”
So who did you pick, honey pie?
I think Edwards can easily lose this, sweetie dick. He's had plenty of time off. Frankly, the reason I think he shouldn't be ranked is cuz the UFC should have a precedent for inactivity, and 18 months is well long enough to qualify. Now sure, it's not all been his fault: other UK employees have said no one's been quite as unlucky as Edwards in current circumstances, but in my opinion, rejecting the Wonderboy offer was inexcusable.
Had he stayed active, even taking bullshit fights, he should be ranked right around where he is. THAT'S the lone problem I've pointed out in this thread, not who wins. The point is: If Edwards
is ranked, he
should be ranked around where he is, at least nowhere lower than 7, because only a small handful of people can argue better accomplishments at that weight (though that's also largely because of diva top fighters who don't take risky fights, which is a list that now includes him after rejecting Wonderboy). If he's
not in the rankings, it should purely be because of being ineligible due to inactivity. Because of that inactivity, how he comes back is the biggest variable. Whether or not Khamzat destroys him can play heavily on that factor.
Now I'm not sure why some people can't wrap their minds around this, but let me let you in on a little trade secret. You can actually
favor one guy, and still not be surprised if he loses. Assuming no problems coming back, Edwards should be favored, but even then, losing wouldn't surprise me. I wouldn't ever be confident in a guy coming off 18 months inactivity, but again, that was never my point. Anyone who thinks it was is because they can't read or think. Which, let's be fair, is at least half of Sherdog.