Jeffrey Dahmer vs. John Wayne Gacy - Who's the scariest killer (Double Overtime) ?

[Takes Two To Tango]

Part One
Part Two
Part Three
Semi-Finals
The Finals
Finals Overtime

Just thought I'd make another round for this tournament to make it conclusive.

Jeffrey Lionel Dahmer, also known as the Milwaukee Cannibal or the Milwaukee Monster, was an American serial killer and sex offender who committed the murder and dismemberment of seventeen men and boys between 1978 and 1991.

John Wayne Gacy was a sex offender and a serial killer. He assaulted, raped and murdered at least 33 boys and young men in 1960s and 1970s. He tortured and killed all his victims inside his ranch house near Norridge, a village in Norwood Park. He was given death sentence in March 1980 and was executed in May 1994.



Let me know if you don't want to be tagged or be tagged. Thank you.

Please vote.

Spoiler

@Excelsior @HardBoiled @ASUThermo @BB in Crazy!!!! @Axefan4life @Ares Black @HeLLMuTT
@PG29 red0 Jr @Kitafuji @newms84 @Mikeydontgiva @Dizzy @Aldo145 @Other @mmascene
@Zookeeper Gabe @Sunnyvale TP @toaa @Starman @MichiganMMA1978 @Law Talkin’ Guy
@revoltub @rj144 @HOV @Cpt Migraine @Shroud of turinabol @Satan's Daddy. @BFoe @Korben
@UFCIsNOTRigged @Tireur889 @TheMaster @Magooglie @TCE @Tone C @boingyman @Anewt
@ChickenBrother @CZMuayThai11 @hamlin @IDGETKTFO @struckus @sanfranpsycho @scgst4
@steeldragon @SoberAwakening @RayA @Randlewand @Shonuffbrad @Luminosity @Big Dawg
@OkayMate @Mack McMarkles @the ninja @RichardHarrow @Gomi1977 @Texan6533 @Zer
@Razor @Winston Wolf @SummerStriker @Ogata @Fox by the Sea @Rygu @jojoRed @Meatspin
@Grappling_With_My_Gnomies @Supasalta3000 @koquerelle @homer @El Che @HYBRID_CFC
@KnightTemplar @Outkast @Tyrannosaurus rex @benebox @Candy Routure @SaigeVanZant
@Valhoven @Two Crows @Five Fingered Fresh Fist @Cielo_ @sleepwalk @rearnakedchoke
@Kraysla @AFanNotAFighter @GODZILLA213 @aldeniro78 @zapataxiv @Thundarr @the gorilla
@Gandulf @I Am Legion @Osculater @Lovestorm @TheWobbler @Trill850

 

[HeLLMuTT]

Yeah both were living nightmare killers but this dude dressed up like a scary ass clown to get himself around kids... Just terrifying to be honest. Both give me chills thinking about them.

 

[RayA]

Dahmer was a necrophiliac and cannibal for the most part. At least you'd be dead for the shit he'd pull.

Gacy actually tortured his victims.

 

[scgst4]

both were horrible and vile but anytime you are eating your victims or trying to turn them into mindless zombies by injecting acid into their brains makes you a special kind of f'ed up

 

[Jesus X]

Jeffrey dahmer used to rape straight men he raped dudes in the army. The craziest serial killer to me is maybe a ted bundy because he would fly under the radar he could catch me by surprise. I would at least have my guard up with dahmer and gacy they probably had a weird personality or red flags.

 

[Jesus X]

Dahmer was a necrophiliac and cannibal for the most part. At least you'd be dead for the shit he'd pull.

Gacy actually tortured his victims.

Dahmer used to torture and rape his victims too he even did it in the army of all places.
https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/jeffrey-dahmer-army-roommate-claims-090402232.html

 

[Tyrannosaurus rex]

I vote Gacy. Dahmer is fucked up too, but I feel like Gacy is just another level of sinister and sadistic. He actually tortured people for extended periods of time.

 

[AFanNotAFighter]

I guess I would go Gacy.

 

[KnightTemplar]

Gacy. He killed twice the number of victims as Dahmer. And many of his victims suffered for prolonged periods of time.

Both were sick fucks of the highest order, but Gacy takes this.

 

[Sweater of AV]

Finals Overtime was Aug 2022....



Gacy.

 

[Noveltymortar]

Neither one scares me because I wouldn’t be a target for them. They seemed like nice guys actually, as long as you aren’t a supple young man.

 

[GoodBadHBK]

They say most serial killers are homosexuals

 

[rearnakedchoke]

These two could end up in the finals. I’ll have to think this over.
Is this the finals?

 

[IDGETKTFO]

Gacy and its not even close.

 

[Cielo_]

Gacy, killing aside he also lived a more normal life. Owned a business, was involved in politics and had a pretty active social life with his neighbors.

 

[Law Talkin’ Guy]

Gacy because didn’t he also kill some children, hence the whole clown thing?

 

[Osculater]

1st. Gacey
2nd. Dahmer

 

[Starman]

Gacy vs. Dahmer is a blowout win for Gacy. Anyone voting for Dahmer is a zoomer who only knows Dahmer because they saw him on Netflix.

 

[Starman]

Jeffrey dahmer used to rape straight men he raped dudes in the army. The craziest serial killer to me is maybe a ted bundy because he would fly under the radar he could catch me by surprise. I would at least have my guard up with dahmer and gacy they probably had a weird personality or red flags.

I voted for Bundy when he was still in the running. Truly an apex predator. He was more evil than Gacy or Dahmer, and likely had a higher body count than both combined if all their cards were laid on the table.

 

[Starman]

Dahmer killed dudes and ate them because he loved them and never wanted them to leave. A mad, psychotic love, for sure, but not on par with Gacy, who would handcuff his victims and then told them what he was about to do because he got off on seeing the fear in their eyes.

Dahmer had to get drunk before he could carry out his crimes. Gacy just got aroused.

No competition. Dahmer maybe could’ve gone down a different road under different circumstances, perhaps. Gacy was born to kill.