News Israel Adesanya is no longer part of the UFC P4P-Rankings

Do you agree with Izzy being removed from the list?


  • Total voters
    127
F52804813932881D0672CFA1755E6245E2972A87
 
This is part of why their whole "Champ automatically vaults to the top of P4P" kinda bites them in the ass.

If you live by that logic, then when Sean beats longtime champ Izzy, you go "Of course Sean should be higher, he's the champ." And then when he falls at the first hurdle and DDP becomes champ, you go "Of course he should be over both" without reevaluating where Sean goes.

The very point of P4P goes against the idea that "I beat like 20 people, but you beat me, so you're automatically P4P better." If Chael didn't get tapped by Silva, would anyone seriously have been going "There goes the P4P best fighter in the world, Chael Sonnen"? Nah, that's not how it works
 
to be honest, I don't care about this rank, it serves to nothing

I rather see stats about win streak or titles defences

if the rank had some objective criterios would make sense like, you're 3x0 on UFC and you won guys that were 1x1, 2x0 and 2x0, so you have 3 points plus other's guys points: 4, so 7 points, and so on

rank guys are 2 points win, title win is 3, win streak can add something until you lose, idk something like that lol but I think few people would be interesting too

as I said, P4P is useless because they will never fight each other and it's subjective
 
You can’t be 1-3 and feasibly be in the P4P rankings.

Izzy needs to win a fight before you start handing this dude another title shot.
 
Yeah this is a no brainer. He's now 50/50 since beating Costa 4 years ago. There are 4 title fight wins in there, so nothing to scoff at, but it's hard to rank a that kind of record that high.
 
Is Charles next?
 
Back
Top