You seem like a pretty sensible guy.
Bad call, I'm a total wack job.
Please explain to me how a guy who was able to finish a fight in 6 years and had to rely on judges scorecards for "wins", tapped to strikes, and was beaten twice, is somehow better than a man who's NEVER been beaten in the octagon by another man, and has actually never even been ROCKED by another man?
Between Dec 2011 and Dec 2018 Jon's only legit finishes were over guys who had been fighting nothing but MWs for the previous half decade, one of whom was even off a loss at MW. Even if we count the DC rematch as "legit" it's still 5 1/2 years without finishing a legit LHW contender for Jonny Bones. The last time GSP had the gift of defending against someone whose previous handful of fights were a division below it was the LW champion and Georges made him quit on the stool.
Jon said Lyoto had rocked him. Gus put him in hospital. Vitor, a short notice MW, nearly took home Jon's arm.
Those are kind of by the by though. The real answer is that I have divisional depth in my highly artistic and rigorously scientific algorithm.
I'm a fan of spectacle so I'm a fan of 205, and Jonny Bones is my favourite fighter to watch and has been for well over half a decade now, but it's impossible to ignore that his division is so shallow that
- Right in the middle of his triumphant defense streak there are two consecutive middleweights
- Both he and DC have defenses against a "challenger" who had been finished in their previous fight
- Of Jon's first 6 title fights only 1 was against an opponent with better LHW momentum than an active 2-win streak
- Forest Griffin had been champion
You just don't get anywhere near as many of those kinds of shallowness indicators in a deep-ass, beast-rich division like FW, LW or WW. Even big units like Forest himself, Frank Mir, Brendan Schaub and Big John McCarthy, as well as high level coaches like Mike Brown, have openly stated that due to the lack of depth in the heavier divisions the level of difficulty is lower relative to deep divisions like FW, LW and WW. And that's even after you count in the "power factor".
I mean, the second best guy at 205 is one of the most lovable characters in the history of the sport, but if you scaled him P4P to 145, 155 or 170 he wouldn't even be Top 5 in any of those weight classes. There's a real good reason you don't crack the upper echelons of WW if you have a dadbod.