If Manny beats Spence by the miracle of God, is Manny the GOAT over Mayweather?

KillerIsBack V2 said:
I know we all chuckled at the fact Tiddies got banned, but I want him in this thread for the lolz.

RIP turdwell
Click to expand...
Yeah I know what you mean. Maybe the mods could give him partial access to just Manny threads just for our entertainment?
 
mozfonky said:
what kind of logic is this? He lost clearly to mayweather in a stink fight. Only way to fix that is to beat mayweather or maybe do something outlandish like fighting at the same level he's at until he's 90, which may be possible these days.
Click to expand...
eh. I don't really agree. I rate Duran ahead of Hearns for example.

you can lose to guys and be ranked ahead of them
 
KillerIsBack V2 said:
I know we all chuckled at the fact Tiddies got banned, but I want him in this thread for the lolz.

RIP turdwell

The GOAT is Sugar Ray Robinson.

Mayweather schooled and knocked down a fresher version of the Juan Manuel Marquez that KO’d Pac little before it happened.

I would retire too.. whats the point after seeing that?

edit: cherry on top, may is old than pac.
Click to expand...
Wtf @TidWell got banned? That sucks. He’s a good dude. I’m sure he’s got a new account by now at least.
 
XThe GreatestX said:
eh. I don't really agree. I rate Duran ahead of Hearns for example.

you can lose to guys and be ranked ahead of them
Click to expand...
posts like this make me wish Hagler moved up in weight just once...weird he was never tempted to.

the ibf started the SM weight class when he was at his best. Could have easily fucked up that korean bum who held it instead of the time off he had between the Mugabi and Ray bouts.
 
Last edited:
JayE said:
It would be a remarkable win. With the whole context, maybe his best win and one of the more remarkable wins of the last 50 years. Of course, it's exceptionally unlikely to happen.
Click to expand...

Yeah look at all these people discrediting Spence BEFORE the fight even happens. Imagine if Manny somehow pulls it off. "Spence was just another Broner"
 
JustOnce said:
Yeah look at all these people discrediting Spence BEFORE the fight even happens. Imagine if Manny somehow pulls it off. "Spence was just another Broner"
Click to expand...

I'm not really seeing many people discrediting Spence.
 
XThe GreatestX said:
eh. I don't really agree. I rate Duran ahead of Hearns for example.

you can lose to guys and be ranked ahead of them
Click to expand...

Harry Greb over Tiger Flowers and Gene Tunney
Holyfield over Bowe (though the steroid rumors and/or head butting of Holyfield always leaves people skeptical about him)
Jack Johnson over Jess Willard
Marquez had a couple losses over guys he is overall ranked better than.
 
don't quote me! said:
Conversely, the better Pacquaio does now, the better Floyd's win over manny looks
Click to expand...

Naw.

He only has himself to blame when he waited for a twice beaten, once KTFO, older slower Pacquiao.

That’s what changed to just a good win from an atg win like Foreman / Ali or Leonard / Hearns.

Pacquiao doing good now just shows how far these two were compared to the present guys and how Pacquiao wasn’t as washed up / completely done as some claimed, when he fought Floyd.
 
Manny definitely is the more exciting fighter of 2. But no ...... even if Manny beat Spence, Crawford back to back its no. May won against Pac n did so easy. May never lost a fight . I would love to rank a much more fan friendly Pac ahead but u can't.
 
Mayweathers reflexes are second to none, thats what a lifetime of being disclipline does for you, he runs 8 miles a day even when not in training....and has never had a drink of alcohol
 
floyd fighting a clown made him lost value as the goat but manny have 7 losses so idk
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Forum statistics

Threads
1,236,986
Messages
55,459,441
Members
174,787
Latest member
Freddie556

Share this page

Back
Top