If Manny beats Floyd

[JustOnce]

Is he the greatest of all time?

If Floyd beats Manny, as great as he is, he beat someone smaller, shorter, who lost before, knocked out cold a few fights ago, and etc, though I believe it is a huge feather on anyone's cap, whether they are undefeated or not, but I feel that some people could bring up something like that and maybe doesn't give Floyd as much credit as he may otherwise deserve.

However, if Manny does pull it off, he would become for the very first time history a linear champion in five different weight division and beating the guy who has never lost before who is naturally bigger and taller.

 

[Cheese]

Fuck No. Only someone who doesn't Know Shit About About Boxing would think that.

 

[Shael]

Nah.

 

[Wanderlei4Life]

No one is ever gonna past sugar Ray Robinson but pac would be top 5-10 no doubt. No one in history will ever win 8 division titles ever. He was the first to win 4 lineal Divison titles. If he beats floyd he will be 5 division lineal champion. No one in history will touch that.

He's not a perfect techinical fighter which is why people hate on him. But his heart and warrior spirit is what really makes him truly ATG. He's improved leaps and bounds over the years which most pro fighters don't do. Their already made fighters when they turn pro.

 

[prikoke]

No one is ever gonna past sugar Ray Robinson but pac would be top 5-10 no doubt. No one in history will ever win 8 division titles ever. He was the first to win 4 lineal Divison titles. If he beats floyd he will be 5 division lineal champion. No one in history will touch that.

He's not a perfect techinical fighter which is why people hate on him. But his heart and warrior spirit is what really makes him truly ATG. He's improved leaps and bounds over the years which most pro fighters don't do. Their already made fighters when they turn pro.

In thirty years they will have 50 weight classes and some dude will win 15 division titles. Those numbers are very inflated.

That's like saying Michael Phelps was a better Olympic athlete than Karelin because Karelin only won 3 gold medals and Phelps won 69.

 

[Seano]

In thirty years they will have 50 weight classes and some dude will win 15 division titles. Those numbers are very inflated.

That's like saying Michael Phelps was a better Olympic athlete than Karelin because Karelin only won 3 gold medals and Phelps won 69.

The titles are overrated, the lineal championships are not.

 

[Wanderlei4Life]

That's stupid. There won't be more weight classes than now because it's already separated by 5-7lbs.

You obviously don't know shit about boxing so don't speak upon it idiot.

 

[prikoke]

True, but they mean less now that fighters move up and down in weight, and vacate one title to get another. A guy who stayed undefeated at one weight class for 15 years would only hold one lineal championship. Manny lost two fights recently and holds 4.

 

[prikoke]

That's stupid. There won't be more weight classes than now because it's already separated by 5-7lbs.

You obviously don't know shit about boxing so don't speak upon it idiot.

been sharing some of Wandy's steroids have we? Chill out, I was just making a point. Do I need to spell out for you what I actually meant?

 

[sportkillergreg]

if manny beats floyd it would make Juan Manuel Marquez the greatest of all time

 

[Seano]

if manny beats floyd it would make Juan Manuel Marquez the greatest of all time

 

[sportkillergreg]

3 good fights and 1 KO against Pacquiao > Bradley barely beating Marquez once

 

[Seano]

3 good fights and 1 KO against Pacquiao > Bradley barely beating Marquez once

1-1 with Pac and a win over Marquez. Bradley beat Marquez clearly.

 

[memphis0789]

lol floyd could lose this fight and still be the greatest of an era manny will never be in serious goat talks top 5 for sure the actual goat not even close he has lost to decisively to ever be the greatest imho. you cant get koed by a guy youve already beaten twice and still be the greatest it just doesnt work that way.

 

[sportkillergreg]

1-1 with Pac and a win over Marquez. Bradley beat Marquez clearly.

beating someone clearly meaning by a round? lol. 1-1 with Pac but is actually 0-2 with Pac. Lost both fights with Pac clearly.

 

[Seano]

beating someone clearly meaning by a round? lol. 1-1 with Pac but is actually 0-2 with Pac. Lost both fights with Pac clearly.

No, he is 1-1 with Pac. Your opinion is irrelevant. Bradley has a win over Pac, regardless of how you saw the fight.

 

[farfan]

Bradley clearly outboxed Marquez in that fight .

not sure why some people saw it as a close fight .

 

[Seano]

Bradley clearly outboxed Marquez in that fight .

not sure why some people saw it as a close fight .

Because a judge gave it to Marquez.

 

[deathstalker]

1-1 with Pac and a win over Marquez. Bradley beat Marquez clearly.

He lost to Pac both times, and the Marquez fight could have gone either way. Marquez was 80 years old as well...

 

[Wanderlei4Life]

lol floyd could lose this fight and still be the greatest of an era manny will never be in serious goat talks top 5 for sure the actual goat not even close he has lost to decisively to ever be the greatest imho. you cant get koed by a guy youve already beaten twice and still be the greatest it just doesnt work that way.

You don't know shit about boxing either. Duran lost to hagler and Hearns yet rates higher than both all time.