If Conor wins this fight and goes back and beats aldo again, is he the goat?

[HelloJapan]

Seriously, mods need some sort of rule to curb this dipshittery.

This.

 

[Metallicalabran]

he is the goat already

 

[yellowishtint]

You lonely, OP?
And no.

 

[kumitechamp]

I thought you meant at his weight class, and still the answer is not even close, then I realized you meant p4p, which makes it laughable. Anderson, Jones, GSP defended their titles a shitload of times and beat multiple former champs, and Anderson went up in weight by 20 lbs and absolutely toyed with a recent champ at the time at the 20 lbs higher weight class, and you think that's matched by a guy going 1-1 with a mid-level contender at LW and having 1 title defense at a lower weight?

Anderson, Jones, and GSP still havent done enough to be the consensus GOAT just proves its unattainable. Conor is going to need several title defenses to even be mentioned in conversation.

 

[Mr Wings]

 

[Rum]

And don't forget Nate wasn't even #5 until they announced the matchup. He actually wasn't even top 10 a month before the fight. They bumped him to hype the fight.
http://www.sherdog.com/news/rankings/6/Sherdogs-Official-Mixed-Martial-Arts-Rankings-99897

It was pretty adorable for sure. Dude was on a 2-3 skid.

I'm not surprised motherfucker.

 

[The guest]

 

[The guest]

Careful, you're gonna rustle some hater-jimmies.

You think this fucking clown has a legit point ?

Come on hero... out yourself on Sherdog. I dare ya.

 

[131313]

OMG you guys are so annoying.
Are you all north American?

 

[SoberAwakening]

Definitely not the goat...not even in the goat discussion. However, he would definitely get his swagger back.

 

[milenss]

The GOAT with 1 title defense?

Technically Fedor has 4 (or 3?) title defences. And he's the GOAT so... not that hard to imagine I guess.

 

[dr740]

no

 

[thisISjoel]

He's already the GOAT.

 

[YoungRonniecoleman]

Conor lost 3 months after becoming UFC champion. He can never become goat, he could beat the whole roster now and that loss would still be there.

 

[12ga.]

I'd pay you guys $10 for a Conor subforum

 

[Ninjarobby]

i think we can all agree he would be the fw goat atleast. I don't think even the biggest haters can dispute that. That would be some blind retard hate. Who here wants to claim that. I'm sure someone will.

I feel you can make the argument. However I feel he would need more than one title defence. Beating nate, who is a very good lw. Does not make him the goat