Hypothetical rematch: Mayweather vs Canelo

[CodeBreaker]

With all the rumblings between the two as of late. Who would win in a rematch, at a catchweight for Canelo?

 

[SSgt Dickweed]

Canelo wins at 160 or above imo. He gained skills in the past 6 years and Mayweather looked like like he slowed down a bit since fighting Berto. If Mayweather forces Canelo to fight at 154, Canelo may be depleted enough to lose to Floyd.

 

[borntoloseNOT]

Some people aren't going to give up until Floyd finally loses somehow.

 

[Hagler]

This fight wouldn't make sense.

 

[PUO3]

Canelo would put Floyd to sleep right now. Floyd is not immune to father time.

 

[ssx]

Canelo beats Floyd now. Nobody defeats Father Time.

 

[randomg1t]

Canelo would put Floyd to sleep right now. Floyd is not immune to father time.

this.

the 2013 floyd still takes today's canelo to school, but the floyd of today gets annihilated by canelo.

floyd got old and shitty. it's what happens with time.

 

[HelpYouFall]

Canelo slaughterhouse.

And I say that with the utmost respect for Floyd.

 

[Minowafanatic]

If Mayweather thought he could still beat Canelo then he would probably give him the fight rather than just calling him mean names on Instagram. Mayweather is old and Canelo would stop him at this point.

 

[DeJulez]

Canelo would beat the shit out of him right now

 

[JayE]

He gets beat down by Canelo at this point. It's possible that he could still see the final bell due to his durability and defense, but he sure as hell wouldn't be winning. Even against Berto three years ago he was looking a little shot, and his timing and reflexes looked like shit against McGregor.

 

[Wanderlei4Life]

Canelo has improved a lot.

He was way too young and inexperienced in this first fight. HE was only 23.

 

[Large Hound 77]

I think Floyd still wins, way too crafty

 

[Sir Punchalot]

Ain't happening, because Canelo would be likely to beat him at this point, and Floyd doesn't like fights like that. Besides, he's 41 and retired, and should stay retired and focus on doing something about his spending instead.

 

[Julius_Caesar]

Canelo has improved a lot.

He was way too young and inexperienced in this first fight. HE was only 23.

Young yes inexperienced no. I've repeated this many times on here. The best example is in Thailand there are many muaythai fighters around the age of 16 who can beat other good pro fighters who are in their mid 20 primes because of experience. Canelo turned pro at 15 and had 43 fights before fighting Floyd. Not as good as he is today and at the time obviously not as experienced as Floyd but still he was experienced enough.

 

[Streeter]

Would love for Mayweather to offer Canelo a 80/20 split. On a ppv guaranteed to do 4 million n more buys I think May is really thinking about this would be well over a 120 mil pay day. 10 mil a rd. May Canelo is biggest fight in either boxing or mma that can be made right now.

Mayweather CAN still win at 154. It would be at 154.

 

[dormammu]

Be floyds toughest challenge, but he still wins. Floyd is just to smart, a year or two more though and he probably loses

 

[nastyleft]

Floyd still figures out a way to win. Just cause Canelo was tee'ing off on GGG doesn't mean it's so easy to do that aganist Floyd, yet. GGG has minimal defense, made Canelo look too special....
Floyd aint getting KO'd unless he's completely shot, reflexes completly gone and vision distorted due to a brutal career (which he hasn't had). And if that's the case, I don't see him getting in the ring against Canelo if he's remotely close to being "done" physically. This would probably the LAST year Floyd could come back and still be the top guy at WW/JMW.

 

[PUO3]

Youre all delusional. Canelo would murder him.