The UFC’s seventh offering on Fox was one of the year’s most action-packed cards, with a solid handful of well-made fights ending in thrilling stoppages. However, it was not a perfect evening on April 20 in San Jose, Calif., due to MMA’s ever-present and destructive specter: poor judging. The main event between then-UFC lightweight champ Ben Henderson and challenger Gilbert Melendez -- a fight most felt Melendez deserved by a slim-if-arguable margin -- was the most obvious source of contention, as it was a marquee matchup between two super-elite competitors. However, Melendez was far from the night’s biggest victim. That unfortunate title went to Larkin, a Strikeforce veteran who was given the rawest of
deals in his Octagon debut.
Carmont, who was fresh off of his previous undeserved decision win over Tom Lawlor at UFC 154, pressed forward for the duration of the contest, seeking takedowns on the flashy striking Larkin. However, in spite of his four-or-more-inch height advantage, considerable reach advantage and ostensible wrestling advantage, Carmont struggled to produce any meaningful offense over the 15 minutes, as he was picked apart by counters from the Riverside, Calif., native.
Larking showed off incredible balance and great defensive instincts, defending a single-leg attempt from Carmont in the first round with his ankle wresting on the Frenchman’s shoulder, hopping around on one foot while still punching his foe. It was a microcosm of the fight itself: Carmont doggedly tried for takedowns but mostly failed, while Larkin craftily snuck away and countered with punches, elbows and low kicks. Even when Carmont did get a takedown in the third round, he was hit with a kimura, and Larkin used it to scramble back to his feet.
“Limitless” was hardly that in his bout with Larkin. The Firas Zahabi pupil was 2-for-11 on his takedowns in the fight and accrued no real offense whatsoever. In the first round, Carmont landed a single strike to Larkin’s 11. In the second, he landed eight to Larkin’s 21. All this while he ran forward into counters while failing at takedowns.
Even if someone liked Carmont in the third round, finding a second frame for him seemed dubious. Yet somehow, all three judges -- Michael Bell, Derek Cleary and Edward Collantes -- had it 29-28 for Carmont. Bell and Cleary even saw fit to give Carmont the first round for his one-strike, zero-takedown performance. All too often the word “robbery” is tossed around in MMA, referring to any fight that comes down to a contentious swing round. Here, Larkin won no less than two and most likely won three rounds, while judges literally rewarded his opponent for doing next to nothing. Silicon Valley might be a peachy place to live, but Larkin proved you can still get robbed in San Jose.