You’re right prob consensus goat status. But to be fair had he come along recently he may have gotten some goat status. There is no doubt that the use of “goat” has increased significantly from those days.you summed it up yourself though. It was "love" aka, some hype from the mouth breathers. Look at the forum after every PPV. Every time a new champion wins there is talk about how they are now the goat. machida had hype, there is no doubt about it. He absolutely didn't have consensus as the goat and some unrivaled fighter that will retire undefeated and be god tier though. that is 100% revisionist history.