I have been training at a 10th planet gym where a lot of guys go for foot locks and heel hooks. Even the white belts go for heel hooks, which is something I'm not use to; however, I noticed they don't actual finish the twist of the ankle. They just get the postition and then let go, which I appreciate because sometimes my ego can get in the way of me tapping and I end up getting hurt. Just really nice to train with guys who are willing to give up the submission, so I don't ended up rolling and hurting myself. I'm pretty experienced, but the other gyms I have trained at don't do much leg locks. Anyway, back on to the subject do most of your gyms have a don't finish heel hook policy or is this just a given because of the danger of that particular submission; also, what is a good time to tap to a heel hook. My instructor told me that rolling out of it like I did puts me in risk of tearing my Minicus. Any info would help due to the danger of uncharted foot lock territory. Thanks
I've never trained anywhere where there was a set-in-stone or concrete policy, but I have a very good system that I believe works well.
It does require you and your partner to trust each other though. When you get to a heelhook or reverse heelhook situation, handfight, do all your normal defense stuff, but if you get past their defense and actually lock up the heel, both of you agree beforehand that that is where you stop, and the person with the heelhook can even say "Checkmate?" if the other guy says yea, then restart. If he is being stubborn, just let it go and move to another position with the knowledge that you had the submission.
If the both of you want to work on heelhook escapes, or rolling out of the position, you need to make sure you also talk about that before you roll. You can simply say, "hey if you catch a heelhook don't turn it I may try to roll out." That way he can just roll with you but not turn the heel.
That's not as smart as the first situation though. Once they have the heel really locked in, there's not much you can do, even in a live competition or MMA fight to get out, besides last ditch hail marys.
Just know your partner, communicate, and if they're new, don't go for heelhooks because they may thrash or spazz and crank their own knee by accident. Especially if gi pants are worn.
If you're both pretty experienced, I don't think this is necessary for footlocks, toeholds or kneebars. If you get one of those, just don't be a dick. Those are actually safer than a lot of people give credit. The risk of injury due to untangling after the tap is also severely decreased.
P.S.: That's really cool that even the white belts at your gym have their egos in check and don't crank footlocks and heelhooks on people.
P.P.S. In competition I will always tap as soon as someone grabs my heel. The only time I won't is when/if I ever get to a advanced level finals at GQuest or ADCC (yeah right lol), an MMA fight, or something like that. Then I'm going "to the death" (c) BJ Penn.