i like GSP but his stans are the worst. Under no circumstance is GSP better than Jon Jones. GSP left at the perfect time right when USADA was about to be implemented. He roided up and got off cycle against arguably the easiest champ to beat, Bisping. Then he retired yet again so he could get back on cycle and do the same thing.
Not to mention, GSP lost to Matt Serra of all people, a 5'6 bantamweight and tapped to strikes. Not to mention his other loss against Matt Hughes.
To anyone who thinks GSP is clean, he walked around 195lbs at around 9-10% bodyfat at 5'9. Not to mention, his hgh gut, traps and other signs of steroid use.
GSP is definitely in the top 5 but Jones is easily 1. There's no denying that at this point. He's simply the GOAT.
St-Pierre's physique is not nearly as absurd as you make it out to be.
If you wanna see freaks (who benefitted from the less strict drug testing during that era) look at Thiago Alves etc.
Also: height doesn't mean as much as you're implying.
Max Holloway and Gökhan Saki are pretty much the same height, yet they're vastly different in size, despite not being too far apart in terms of body fat percentage.
That's because of their different frame-size.
Also: i highly doubt that if he ever walked around at 195 pounds that he was anywhere near as shredded as you make him out to be.
Another thing is the supposed hgh gut... do you seriously think that fighters took more hgh than some bodybuilders?
Because i fail to see how that could be the case.
Anyways, St-Pierre's "huge" physique came from his broad shoulders, wide ribcage and his thick joints.
His muscle bellys are not exactly big.
Here's a picture of him where he hasn't got a pump, is under anabolic light and had sweat on him:
Hardly spectacular...
But even if you assume St-Pierre was on something: he fought during an era with less strict testing, whereas Jones has been proven to be on PEDs during an era with the most strict testing in MMA to date.
Not to mention the difference in talentpool between welterweight and light heavyweight.