GSP Resume vs Silva Resume

[The Domin8or]

Alright lets start with GSP resume

Matt Hughes(2xWW Champ) 2x
B.J Penn (LW and WW Champ) 2x
Johny Hendricks (WW Champ)
Michael Bisping (MW Champ)
Carlos Condit (Interim WW Champ)
Jake Shields
Josh Koscheck 2x
Jon Fitch
Nick Diaz
Thiago Alves
Sean Sherk (Lightweight Champ)
Matt Serra(WW Champ)
Dan Hardy(Still a better win than many of silva wins)

-----------------------------------------
Dan Henderson
Chael Sonnen 2x
Vitor Belfort(LHW Champ)
Rich Franklin 2x(MW Champ)
Derek Brunson
Nate Marquardt
Forrest Griffin(LHW Champ)
Demian Maia
Nick Diaz


GSP's resume is better by a long shot . GSP has the GOAT mma resume (Jones resume is a close second )
Hate him or like him you have to accept that GSP is the greatest of all time his resume and the way he dominated his opponents speak for himself .

 

[reddhelium]

well damn, your detailed analysis just slams the door shut on this argument.

 

[20falarVerdades]

Can't be goat without finishing fights

 

[loisestrad]

Silva lost vs Bisping. GSP beat Bisping, while going up in weight class and coming from a year long hiatus.

Case closed.

 

[The Domin8or]

Can't be goat without finishing fights

Silva's fights against brunson , nick , leites , maia were way more boring than any gsp fight . Also you cant be GOAT if you test 3 times for PEDs

 

[Brock-B-level-Athlete]

 

[Sansnom]

This again?

 

[wilKO]

You just ignoring Hendos 2 world titles in 2 weight classes then?

 

[Reach4theSky]

Not saying who is better but this is their ''UFC resumes". GSP had only 5 fights in the bush leagues before entering the UFC. Whereas Anderson had 21, fighting in top orgs like Pride and Cage Rage...

 

[The Domin8or]

You just ignoring Hendos 2 world titles in 2 weight classes then?

I wanted tou put that out there for Hendo but it would've been unfair to not put jake shields belts outside the ufc too .

Not saying who is better but this is their ''UFC resumes". GSP had only 5 fights in the bush leagues before entering the UFC. Whereas Anderson had 21, fighting in top orgs like Pride and Cage Rage...

Yeah fighting top competition like Lee MUrray , Jorge Rivera right ? and getting subbed by japanese cans in pride

 

[wilKO]

I wanted tou put that out there for Hendo but it would've been unfair to not put jake shields belts outside the ufc too .

Not comparable at all. Pride had the best fighters in the world when Hendo won his titles. Pride belts are equal to UFC belts. No other belts are equal to Pride and UFC belts.

 

[The Domin8or]

Not comparable at all. Pride had the best fighters in the world when Hendo won his titles. Pride belts are equal to UFC belts. No other belts are equal to Pride and UFC belts.

Yeah true , But the ithing is that Jake Shields is still a better win than hendo (Who might be the best silva win)

 

[wilKO]

Yeah true , But the ithing is that Jake Shields is still a better win than hendo (Who might be the best silva win)

No it's not. Hendo is a top 10 GOAT. Shields is lucky to make top 30. The only wins GSP has comparable to Hendo are Hughes and BJ and to be honest neither of those guys seem to get ranked ahead of Hendo on all time lists that Sherdog make regularly.

 

[HNIC215]

 

[The Domin8or]

No it's not. Hendo is a top 10 GOAT. Shields is lucky to make top 30. The only wins GSP has comparable to Hendo are Hughes and BJ and to be honest neither of those guys seem to get ranked ahead of Hendo on all time lists that Sherdog make regularly.

But shields dominated hendo lol Also hendo didnt had that much of a success in pride either besides winning 2 belts .

 

[Fatback96]

Nah here's the real GOAT

 

[ThunderStruck]

GSP's resume is also far more impressive when you take a look at contexts of the fights. He beat guys in their absolute prime at the peak of their momentum, riding insane win streaks.

Silva fought guys who lost 2-3 fights ago most of the times and the one time he fought someone on a good momentum he got KTFO and lost the rematch.

 

[ThunderStruck]

No it's not. Hendo is a top 10 GOAT. Shields is lucky to make top 30. The only wins GSP has comparable to Hendo are Hughes and BJ and to be honest neither of those guys seem to get ranked ahead of Hendo on all time lists that Sherdog make regularly.

Sorry but Shields is a much better win than Hendo. Shields was riding an insane win streak including a total domination against Hendo who is one weight class bigger. Hendo is so overrated all he has is a right hand and he stopped using his wrestling effectively. Never developped good BJJ and already lost many many times before facing Silva.

The only reason Hendo is ranked high on all time list is because he fought for so long thanks to abusing a drug that makes you 20 years younger.

 

[Deleted member 549255]

Anderson’s resume is superior

 

[HelloJapan]

Oh its 2010 again.