- Joined
- May 19, 2003
- Messages
- 53,511
- Reaction score
- 7,146
peanut butter said:isnt the hub training your whole hand like the block?
Yeah, but you can't snatch or press a hub attached to a loading pin.
peanut butter said:isnt the hub training your whole hand like the block?
peanut butter said:for the purposes of training your grip wouldnt a hub with a loading pin be better, because you can add more weight
A heavier blockweight is also wider and has more sloped sides and his therefore harder to hold onto for several reasons. and sonny is right, there are ways to add weight to a blockweight, but IMO, it's unecessary until you can lift the blob (head of a 100 lb db)peanut butter said:for the purposes of training your grip wouldnt a hub with a loading pin be better, because you can add more weight
cfiore6006 said:Okay, first: Yes, I am a fucking newbie. Now that I've admitted it, no one else has to bring it up.
Second: why would I want to train grip and press / snatch at the same time? If I want to work grip, I'll work grip, if I want to press, I'll press, and by God, if I want to do cleans, I'll clean.
Is there some benefit to cleaning weights I can't wrap my whole hand around the way I can a bar? If I'm doing shoulder presses (or whatever), I'm not really working grip much, am I?
well, yeah there is an added benefit. I have sometimes fantasized about a gym with an assortment of thick barbells and dumbells ranging from 1" all the way up to 3". People in this gym would ask themselves the following question on any exercise they had to grip the weight to perform, "can I hold onto the weight easily?" and if the answer is yes, they need a thicker bar. This would apply to rows, deadlifts, pullups, curls, oly movements, etc.cfiore6006 said:why would I want to train grip and press / snatch at the same time? If I want to work grip, I'll work grip, if I want to press, I'll press, and by God, if I want to do cleans, I'll clean.
Is there some benefit to cleaning weights I can't wrap my whole hand around the way I can a bar? If I'm doing shoulder presses (or whatever), I'm not really working grip much, am I?
to prove you're not paying attention I'll quote myself in a post I just made earlier in the thread.tommboy said:Why would I want to do olympic lifts???????? or any of that other stuff?
Urban said:well, yeah there is an added benefit. I have sometimes fantasized about a gym with an assortment of thick barbells and dumbells ranging from 1" all the way up to 3". People in this gym would ask themselves the following question on any exercise they had to grip the weight to perform, "can I hold onto the weight easily?" and if the answer is yes, they need a thicker bar. This would apply to rows, deadlifts, pullups, curls, oly movements, etc.
Now, asside from simply making grip another factor in existing exercises, the demand for stabilizing and reacting to moving an object that is difficult to hold onto on your lower arms is very useful. I mean, in a thickbar clean the catch is very different to accomodate the wider bar, and the stress on the wrists differs as well. The same can be said about blockweight oly movments, you have to stabilize that blockweight in your hand. this takes additional thumb, finger and wrist strength all working together to form a vicelike grip. Consider KB presses with the bell up and the handle down (pavel has a name for these I just can't recall it right now). This takes a lot of effort to keep the bell from coming down and crashing into your forearm.
Lastly, pulling an object from the floor with the power to move it overhead or to clean position in one swift movment is more demanding on the grip. You have to suddenly wrench down your grip on it and then keep that grip solid through quite a complex movment. there's a lot to be said for being able to do that, which gives these feats a merit of their own. consider how much more difficult it is to clean the inch DB rather than just deadlift it.
Got it. This makes sense to me. Pavel calls it a "Bottoms Up Press", by the way.Urban said:Now, asside from simply making grip another factor in existing exercises, the demand for stabilizing and reacting to moving an object that is difficult to hold onto on your lower arms is very useful. I mean, in a thickbar clean the catch is very different to accomodate the wider bar, and the stress on the wrists differs as well. The same can be said about blockweight oly movments, you have to stabilize that blockweight in your hand. this takes additional thumb, finger and wrist strength all working together to form a vicelike grip. Consider KB presses with the bell up and the handle down (pavel has a name for these I just can't recall it right now). This takes a lot of effort to keep the bell from coming down and crashing into your forearm.
RickoOodles said:*Thread hijack* Has anyone tried kettlebells? They seem tempting, and old school.