Georges St-Pierre has the most wins against former/current/future UFC champions in MMA History

[grimballer]

So is that what Fedor did?

What way? Falling off?

There’s a difference between being top fighter for almost 10 years n then eventually losing n being a journeyman, have 2 or 3 good performances, get a title shot, lose n then go back to journeyman status.

 

[strat597]

What way? Falling off?

There’s a difference between being top fighter for almost 10 years n then eventually losing n being a journeyman, have 2 or 3 good performances, get a title shot, lose n then go back to journeyman status.

That's what I'm saying. Logically, could it be that Fedor was never that great by the earlier statements in the post? I don't think that's the case but that is what was explained about the fighters GSP beat. They were great before they lost but after the loss, they were no longer "great"

 

[ferrari]

What way? Falling off?

There’s a difference between being top fighter for almost 10 years n then eventually losing n being a journeyman, have 2 or 3 good performances, get a title shot, lose n then go back to journeyman status.

Most GSP opponents were coming off long winning streaks when they fought the GOAT . Even a past of it Post-GSP Jake Shields went on to defeat current top 10 welterweights Tyron Woodley and Demian Maia .
Its just that when they fought the GOAT and saw his greatness and got punished by him for 5 rounds something was broken in them .

 

[GTS]

Georges and Jon both beat 6 different former/current/future undisputed champions. Hespect

GSP beat 7

 

[grimballer]

That's what I'm saying. Logically, could it be that Fedor was never that great by the earlier statements in the post? I don't think that's the case but that is what was explained about the fighters GSP beat. They were great before they lost but after the loss, they were no longer "great"

You’re comparing apples n oranges

That argument would make sense if fedor got dominated by big nog n after that became .500 fighter exchanging wins n losses.

However that’s not what happen. Fedor beat no.1 hw in big nog n continue dominating the division for another 7 years before losing

Someone like Bret Rogers would be a better example.

He was undefeated with 10-0 record n beat top guy in arlovski in 30 seconds

Then he faced fedor n after good 1st round got finished.

After he became a journeyman

So was he really any good or did fedor “took his soul”?

 

[grimballer]

Most GSP opponents were coming off long winning streaks when they fought the GOAT . Even a past of it Post-GSP Jake Shields went on to defeat current top 10 welterweights Tyron Woodley and Demian Maia .
Its just that when they fought the GOAT and saw his greatness and got punished by him for 5 rounds something was broken in them .

Who did they beat during those long winning streaks?

Also nobody got really punished by gsp, expect maybe Fitch n he was the only one not to completely fall off.

Most of the time gsp would look worse than his opponent, so that tells you he didn’t do any real damage n mostly controlled his opponent which shouldn’t lead to them “losing their souls” n start losing to average fighters

 

[strat597]

You’re comparing apples n oranges

That argument would make sense if fedor got dominated by big nog n after that became .500 fighter exchanging wins n losses.

However that’s not what happen. Fedor beat no.1 hw in big nog n continue dominating the division for another 7 years before losing

Someone like Bret Rogers would be a better example.

He was undefeated with 10-0 record n beat top guy in arlovski in 30 seconds

Then he faced fedor n after good 1st round got finished.

After he became a journeyman

So was he really any good or did fedor “took his soul”?

I don't understand this post. Fedor didn't get dominated by Nog and become a 500 fighter. Neither did GSP. But GSP didn't get dominated later on in his career the way Fedor did. And before you say out of prime..he was still considered top heavyweight until the Werdum loss.

 

[Magnum1978]

I don't understand this post. Fedor didn't get dominated by Nog and become a 500 fighter. Neither did GSP. But GSP didn't get dominated later on in his career the way Fedor did. And before you say out of prime..he was still considered top heavyweight until the Werdum loss.

To be fair - if Fedor 'retired' when GSP did (at 32) he'd have been 30-1 (effectively 30-0) after KO'ing arlovski... then he would have taken a few years off to heal himself and come back and fight say Brock (effectively equivalent to Bisping) for the title, then rode off to the sunset

 

[grimballer]

I don't understand this post. Fedor didn't get dominated by Nog and become a 500 fighter. Neither did GSP. But GSP didn't get dominated later on in his career the way Fedor did. And before you say out of prime..he was still considered top heavyweight until the Werdum loss.

Hmmm...

Gsp was gifted a decision n retired from the sport at age 32 with 27 pro fights.

Fedor started losing at age 34 n with 34 pro fights.

Would gsp be able to fight another 2 or 3 years n stay undefeated?

Also how’s that relevant to this discussion?

N comparable to someone like Thiago Alves who after 10-5 start went on an impressive 7 fight win streak, face n lost to gsp n became .500 fighter at age 26 n 23 pro fights?

 

[Law Dog]

Matt Hughes(Two-time UFC WW champion , #2 WW GOAT) 2x
BJ Penn (UFC LW&WW champion , Many people claim him to be the LW GOAT) 2x
Johny Hendricks ( UFC WW champion)
Michael Bisping (UFC MW champion)
Sean Sherk (UFC LW champion)
Carlos Condit (UFC WW interim champion)
Matt Serra (UFC WW champion)
GSP resume contains 9 victories against UFC champions . No wonder why he is considered by the majority of MMA fans and pundits as the GOAT.
Most of these fighters were in their absolute fighting prime when they fought Georges , Yet that wasnt enough since they were fighting the greatest fighter of all time whos name is Georges St-Pierre . The only two persons that could get a victory against the greatest were brutally finished in the rematches against the GOAT in which GSP showed why he clearly was the superior fighter to them .

Tell us something we don’t know... He’s the clear GOaT! Anyone else is peanuts.