- Joined
- Sep 26, 2012
- Messages
- 5,161
- Reaction score
- 15
He is good, but he is no steve mazzagatti. That man will throw his body in front of you to save you. Gotta admire his work ethic, even if he makes a mistake on occasion.
So will Herb Dean.
I think Mario, Yves, Big John, and Josh are the best.
No one should say josh rosenthal is a good ref after he almost let munoz die against weidman.
Mario reffed the Glover/Maldonado fight.Mario is one of the best. He has 1 really bad call in recent memory (silva-prater)
Rosenthal is pretty underrated. IMO he should be right up there with Big John and Herb.
yeah that was bad. But then look at Herb Dean for Struve vs. Morecraft.
I don't think you can judge anybody on 1 or 2 calls, you have to look at the full body of work.
So for example Jeff Malott is better than yama?
People should give a little bit of slack for the refs, not Jeff, but to the other ones for early stoppages etc. Dont get me wrong, I am fucking furious, if the ref stops the fight too early, but I can still undestand it and realize their job is quite hard.
Its always easy to look at the replays in slowmotion, but it aint so easy to call it in the heat of the action (again Jeffs reffing being the exclusion). But ignorant know-it-alls of course know better. Too bad their talents are usually wasted on the internet forums.
I have not because people would drown lol
Mario reffed the Glover/Maldonado fight.
Out of curiosity can you name 9 better reffs then him?