There are fans of skill that respect a performance, athletic ability, intelligent tactics and can recognize improvement. If it is there it usually results in a win -- preferably a dominating finish to prove the athlete's superior abilities (physical and mental).
Then there are glassy-eyed followers who defend a name even when that name displays average or sub-par skills.
A real fan doesn't wear rose tinted glasses. They see a performance for what it is. Rory's performance was not impressive -- he says he wants to be a "dominant" champion but he is no where near that. Just being able to "hang" with top level fighters for a bit isn't good enough.
Tristar athletes on the whole seem to hit a plateau and can go no further. It happened to Rory. Maybe it is mental weakness, lack of discipline, motivation, or lack of high level trainers and training partners, who knows. But there is a definite weakness at that gym.