Don't mention GSP's name in the same sentence as Fedor.

[truthisfreedom]

Hi guys! Let's compare a middleweight sized guy who destroys HWs 50 lbs heavier than him, to a guy who was afraid to move up 15 lbs and fight Silva for years.

While we're at it, let's compare a guy who mostly DESTROYED his competition, to a guy who went a decade without being able to finish a single fighter in his weightclass.

Also, let's compare a guy a guy who KO'd Tim Sylvia 2x his size, to a guy who got TKO'd (and tapped to strikes) against 5'5 Matt Serra LULZ


Seems legit!






Fedor is one of the GOATS.

Do not mention GSP's name in the same sentence. Please and thank you.

 

[Mixfight]

Fedor is the GOAT.
GSP is a close second.

 

[BTard]

GSP and Fedor. Fedor and GSP.
Fuck off with your wasteland quality thread.

 

[AC1D1K]

guess wat? both good!~

 

[JustBleed69]

Hi guys! Let's compare a middleweight sized guy who destroys HWs 50 lbs heavier than him, to a guy who was afraid to move up 15 lbs and fight Silva for years.

While we're at it, let's compare a guy who mostly DESTROYED his competition, to a guy who went a decade without being able to finish a single fighter in his weightclass.

Also, let's compare a guy a guy who KO'd Tim Sylvia 2x his size, to a guy who got TKO'd (and tapped to strikes against 5'5 Matt Serra LULZ


Seems legit!
View attachment 375649 View attachment 375651





Fedor is one of the GOATS.

Do not mention GSP's name in the same sentence. Please and thank you.

Fedor lost to Fabio Maldono, Mitrione, and Bigfoot lol

 

[fightfan70]

fedor = goat

gsp = manlet goat?

 

[Summoning]

What about like both???

 

[DS66]

I hate that size argument. There's weight classes for a reason. What GSP did in his weight class was amazing and virtually unprecedented.

Fedor's accomplishments are amazing as well. It's impossible to compare them and come out with an objective GOAT. It's simply not possible. So you can't be upset if someone doesn't agree with you, that's the nature of the GOAT discussion in this sport.

 

[truthisfreedom]

Fedor is the GOAT.
GSP is a close second.

Silva/Fedor/Jones are the GOATS.

GSP is a good fighter, who can't touch any of the GOATs

 

[lweiberg]

 

[HwoarangStyle]

Georges St-Pierre is better and more GOATY than Fedor Emelienenko.

 

[Dorkman]

You guys are so petty when it comes to discussing "goat" lists. Christ give it a rest. They're both truly unique talent and athletes that won't ever be truly matched in how they approached and succeeded at the game.

 

[oldschoolmmafan]

Both are legends and real martial artists inside and outside the cage. I understand the reasoning behind each one's claim as greatest of all time but to say GSP shouldn't be mentioned in same sentence is just idiotic.

 

[gono btw]

I hate that size argument. There's weight classes for a reason. What GSP did in his weight class was amazing and virtually unprecedented.

Fedor's accomplishments are amazing as well. It's impossible to compare them and come out with an objective GOAT. It's simply not possible. So you can't be upset if someone doesn't agree with you, that's the nature of the GOAT discussion in this sport.

The GOAT concept is related to a set of criterias.

Some have a set of criterias that is satisfied by fighters like No Rush, others dont.

That´s it.

 

[Summoning]

 

[Gabe]

No one will ever agree but both guys are legends. It's like comparing Jordan and Lebron.

 

[cade187]

As someone who thinks both fighters are garbage, I love all these GSP vs. Fedor threads. lol

 

[VAfan]

stupid fanboy post. nothing to see here, move along.

 

[josp1]

Also, let's compare a guy a guy who KO'd Tim Sylvia 2x his size, to a guy who got TKO'd (and tapped to strikes) against 5'5 Matt Serra LULZ


Seems legit!
View attachment 375649 View attachment 375651

Well...fedor got knocked out by Dan Henderson who was much smaller than fedor.

So there's that

 

[TheRassler]

Well...fedor got knocked out by Dan Henderson who was much smaller than fedor.

So there's that

and there's this.