Urban said:
Asside from the complete lack of specificity, I don't like it cause there's no clear way to guage progress.
I can't believe I'm going to disagree with Urban.
I'm no staunch defender of Crossfit. IMHO, they do as much wrong as they do right. However, I give them props for constantly enforcing the "time dynamic" in their workouts. In other words, many of the workouts are timed so as to decrease the amount of time to do the workout ("Fran" comes to mind), or to do more work (sets) in a given amount of time ("Helen" comes to mind). They also do those gay ass max effort days (5,3,2,2,1,1,1,1,1...or some shit like that).
So, I'd argue that they do have some guidelines to measure progress through the time element, as well as the fact that they want you to move up your maxes on certain key lifts.
Having said that...if you ever want the biggest fucking laugh of your life then go to the Crossfitlive website and download the audio interviews. The Greg Glassman and "women of Crossfit" interviews are classic examples of why people call them a cult. They hardly talk about training at all...they basically sit around and call each other "fitness legends", and Glassman thinks that anyone who doesn't do Crossfit has "character issues".
It's a neat program, but at the end of the day 90% of their most vocal proponents are nothing but brainwashed sheep. They make the Dragondoor comrades seem well-adjusted by comparison.